Exploring Upper-6 GHz and mmWave in Urban 5G Networks: A Direct on-Field Comparison

The increasing demand for mobile bandwidth is driving 5G networks toward the use of high-frequency spectrum, particularly the upper-6 GHz and mmWave bands. While these bands offer vast bandwidth potential, their propagation characteristics raise critical deployment challenges. This paper presents the first direct, on-field comparative evaluation of 5G standalone (SA) macro-cell deployments operating in these two bands, conducted in Milan, Italy. We show that the upper-6 GHz band can deliver wide-area urban coverage (up to 600 meters) with stable gigabit-level downlink throughput, even in (NLoS) scenarios. mmWave, traditionally deemed unsuitable for NLoS, exhibits strong performance via urban reflections, achieving up to 1.3 Gbps in downlink and 250 Mbps in uplink. Furthermore, outdoor-to-indoor connectivity at mmWave frequencies proves viable through glass facades, challenging pessimistic assumptions about penetration losses. These findings, derived from synchronized deployments and extensive measurements, provide new insights into the complementary roles of these bands and the practical feasibility of their integration into future 5G networks.