The Crucial Role of Data Quality Control in Hydrochemical Studies: Reevaluating Groundwater Evolution in the Jiangsu Coastal Plain, China

A vital step for any hydrochemical assessment is properly carrying out quality assurance and quality control (QA/QC) techniques to evaluate data confidence before performing the assessment. Understanding the processes governing groundwater evolution in coastal aquifers is critical for managing freshwater resources under increasing anthropogenic and climatic pressures. This study reassesses the hydrochemical and isotopic data from the Deep Confined Aquifer System (DCAS) in the Jiangsu Coastal Plain, China, by firstly applying QA/QC protocols. Anomalously high Fe and Mn concentrations in several samples were identified and excluded, yielding a refined dataset that enabled a more accurate interpretation of hydrogeochemical processes. Using hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA), principal component analysis (PCA), and stable and radioactive isotope data (δ2H, δ18O, 3H, and 14C), we identify three dominant drivers of groundwater evolution: water–rock interaction, evaporation, and seawater intrusion. In contrast to earlier interpretations, we present clear evidence of active seawater intrusion into the DCAS, supported by salinity patterns, isotopic signatures, and local hydrodynamics. Furthermore, inconsistencies between tritium- and radiocarbon-derived residence times—modern recharge indicated by 3H versus Pleistocene ages from 14C—highlight the unreliability of previous paleoclimatic reconstructions based on unvalidated datasets. These findings underscore the crucial role of robust QA/QC and integrated tracer analysis in groundwater studies.