Understanding the Aero-mechanical Behavior of a MGB Cooling Fan

The oil cooling fan of a Main Gearbox (MGB) is a mechanically-driven component whose purpose is to force an air flow through an air cooled oil cooler; its performance is crucial in ensuring that the MGB oil temperature does not exceed a predefined threshold, set to alert the crew in case of an abnormal situation. The design and the certification of a cooling fan is a process involving several steps and multiple disciplines; mechanical design, aerodynamic analysis, dedicated tests carried out both on rigs and at aircraft level need to be exploited as complementary tools to assess the correct aero-mechanical behavior of the system. The aerodynamic assessment is associated to performance, measured in terms of MGB oil temperature: considering a comparison between two cooling fans, one outperforms the other if the resultant MGB oil temperature is lower, keeping the same boundary conditions (engine torque, wind speed, ambient temperature, etc.). The correct mechanical behavior is instead associated to multiple requirements that need to be satisfied: target fatigue life, high and low temperature limits, blade loss containment, maximum speed, etc. The process connecting the very first blank page to the certification of the part is usually linear and well defined, and the experience gathered by Leonardo Helicopters over the years has allowed to follow this path easily in most cases. This paper discusses an intriguing situation: the goal of the activity herein discussed was to replace an obsolete oil cooling fan with a new one. The latter was expected to outperform the first both from the aerodynamic point of view (i.e. lower MGB oil temperature) and from the mechanical point of view (i.e. longer life). The preliminary CFD analyses and the rig tests proved that the new fan was able to outperform the legacy one in regards of the aerodynamic requirement; nevertheless, during the last steps of verification carried out at aircraft level, the installation of the new fan resulted in a higher MGB oil temperature. This triggered dedicated troubleshooting: a sequence of investigative tests performed by means of dedicated rigs, targeted at properly identifying the aerodynamic operative point of the cooling fan and at understanding the reason behind the unexpected outcomes obtained. The relevance of this contribution does not lie in the description of the certification process per se, rather in the nonlinear dynamics characterizing the test sequence once the flight activities pointed out an unpredicted behavior.