Conformational Analysis and Structure-Altering Mutations of the HIV-1 Frameshifting Element

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) continues to be a threat to public health. An emerging technique with promise in the context of fighting HIV type 1 (HIV-1) focuses on targeting ribosomal frameshifting. A crucial -1 programmed ribosomal frameshift (PRF) has been observed in several pathogenic viruses, including HIV-1. Altered folds of the HIV-1 RNA frameshift element (FSE) have been shown to alter frameshifting efficiency. Here, we use RNA-As-Graphs (RAG), a graph-theory based framework for representing and analyzing RNA secondary structures, to perform conformational analysis in motif space to propose how sequence length may influence folding patterns. This combined analysis, along with all-atom modeling and experimental testing of our designed mutants, has already proven valuable for the SARS-CoV-2 FSE. As a first step to launching the same computational/experimental approach for HIV-1, we compare prior experiments and perform SHAPE-guided 2D-fold predictions for the HIV-1 FSE embedded in increasing sequence contexts and predict structure-altering mutations. We find a highly stable upper stem and highly flexible lower stem for the core FSE, with a three-way junction connecting to other motifs at increasing lengths. In particular, we find little support for a pseudoknot or triplex interaction in the core FSE, although pseudoknots can form separately as a connective motif at longer sequences. We also identify sensitive residues in the upper stem and central loop that, when minimally mutated, alter the core stem loop folding. These insights into the FSE fold and structure-altering mutations can be further pursued by all-atom simulations and experimental testing to advance the mechanistic understanding and therapeutic strategies for HIV-1.