Stratigraphic Position and Age of the Upper Triassic Placerias Quarry, East-Central Arizona, USA

The Placerias quarry is a dicynodont-dominated bonebed in Upper Triassic Chinle Group strata near St. Johns in east-central Arizona, USA. Though long identified as being in strata of the lower Chinle Group, recently published numerical ages apparently indicate a stratigraphically much higher (younger) position in the Chinle section for the Placerias quarry. Nevertheless, recent analysis of outcrop and subsurface (hydrologic) data in the vicinity of the Placerias quarry confirms its stratigraphic position very low in the Chinle Group section, close to the base of the Bluewater Creek Formation. A regional Upper Triassic lithostratigraphy has been established across east-central Arizona and west-central New Mexico by nearly a century of stratigraphic studies and geologic mapping by diverse workers, and is supported by biostratigraphy; in this lithostratigraphy the Placerias quarry is near the Chinle Group base. However, U/Pb ages on zircons from Upper Triassic strata in eastern Arizona/western New Mexico have been used to reorganize this lithostratigraphy to indicate intertonguing and dramatic lithofacies changes over relatively short lateral distances. But, if the well-established lithostratigraphy is followed, the U/Pb ages are problematic, particularly where younger ages (such as at the Placerias quarry) are stratigraphically below older ages. A handful of numerical ages should not be used to over-rule well-established understanding of lithostratigraphy and biostratigraphy, unless the lithostratigraphy and biostratigraphy need to be modified based on stratigraphic data. Numerical ages need to be used judiciously and evaluated critically with regard to established lithostratigraphy, biostratigraphy and other age constraints.