Leveraging synthetic trace generation of modeling operations for intelligent modeling assistants using large language models

Context: Due to the proliferation of generative AI models in different software engineering tasks, the research community has started to exploit those models, spanning from requirement specification to code development. Model-Driven Engineering (MDE) is a paradigm that leverages software models as primary artifacts to automate tasks. In this respect, modelers have started to investigate the interplay between traditional MDE practices and Large Language Models (LLMs) to push automation. Although powerful, LLMs exhibit limitations that undermine the quality of generated modeling artifacts, e.g., hallucination or incorrect formatting. Recording modeling operations relies on human-based activities to train modeling assistants, helping modelers in their daily tasks. Nevertheless, those techniques require a huge amount of training data that cannot be available due to several factors, e.g., security or privacy issues. Objective: In this paper, we propose an extension of a conceptual MDE framework, called MASTER-LLM, that combines different MDE tools and paradigms to support industrial and academic practitioners. Method: MASTER-LLM comprises a modeling environment that acts as the active context in which a dedicated component records modeling operations. Then, model completion is enabled by the modeling assistant trained on past operations. Different LLMs are used to generate a new dataset of modeling events to speed up recording and data collection. Results: To evaluate the feasibility of MASTER-LLM in practice, we experiment with two modeling environments, i.e., CAEX and HEPSYCODE, employed in industrial use cases within European projects. We investigate how the examined LLMs can generate realistic modeling operations in different domains. Conclusion: We show that synthetic traces can be effectively used when the application domain is less complex, while complex scenarios require human-based operations or a mixed approach according to data availability. However, generative AI models must be assessed using proper methodologies to avoid security issues in industrial domains.