A Study on the Military Tales(軍談) of <Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok> : Focusing on Comparisons with <Myeongjubowolbing> and <Yunhajeongsammunchwirok>

In this paper, we focused on the “military tales”(軍談) in the Korean novel <Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok>, and compared their existence and characteristics with the previous and original works, <Yunhajeongsammunchwirok> and <Yunhajeongsammunchwirok>, and then attempted to derive their literary historical significance. The military tales in <Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok> took up a considerable amount of space, two volumes based on the 30-volume Naksunjae(樂善齋) version, and not only showed uniqueness that distinguished them from other works, but also strongly revealed continuity with the previous work. In addition, it was confirmed that the creative process of the work took into account the readers’ intention to read the three works consecutively, and therefore it was deemed necessary to deeply examine the issue of the description of the military tales. Through a comparative review of the military tales between the works, it can be confirmed that in the process of retelling the narrative of the previous work, <Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok> expanded and mutated the content corresponding to the military tale, that the military tales, which total 19 times including the previous work, were differentiated from each other through variations in the form of antagonistic characters and the method of confrontation, and that while the activities of the characters corresponding to the direct line of the Um clan were abbreviated or omitted, the activities of the characters of the other clan (他門) who are relatives were specified, weakening the narrative centered on the single clan(一門). Based on the above points, it can be confirmed that the military tales of the three works including <Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok> and <Yunhajeongsammunchwirok> were created with careful consideration for the readers’ ‘continued reading’ of the three works and the heightened interest unique to military tales. In addition, it was inferred that while military tales can be sufficiently attractive stories in the enjoyment of Korean long novels, they can also be factors that divide opinions or reduce interest depending on the reader’s taste and creative style. Finally, considering that the military tales in the work show the direction of strengthening the interrelationship and continuous reading among the three works and the weakening of the narrative centered on one sentence, it was revealed that it is more appropriate to define <Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok> as a trilogy of novels that follows <Yunhajeongsammunchwirok> and <Yunhajeongsammunchwirok>.

Authors

Publication Details

Published
2025-05-31
DOI
https://doi.org/10.20516/classic.2025.69.1181
Primary Topic
Japanese History and Culture
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

A Study on the Military Tales(軍談) of <Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok> : Focusing on Comparisons with <Myeongjubowolbing> and <Yunhajeongsammunchwirok>

Jeong-hyeon Seo
Japanese History and Culture
article

A Study on the Military Tales(軍談) of <Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok> : Focusing on Comparisons with <Myeongjubowolbing> and <Yunhajeongsammunchwirok>

Jeong-hyeon Seo
article en

Abstract

In this paper, we focused on the “military tales”(軍談) in the Korean novel &lt;Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok&gt;, and compared their existence and characteristics with the previous and original works, &lt;Yunhajeongsammunchwirok&gt; and &lt;Yunhajeongsammunchwirok&gt;, and then attempted to derive their literary historical significance. The military tales in &lt;Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok&gt; took up a considerable amount of space, two volumes based on the 30-volume Naksunjae(樂善齋) version, and not only showed uniqueness that distinguished them from other works, but also strongly revealed continuity with the previous work. In addition, it was confirmed that the creative process of the work took into account the readers’ intention to read the three works consecutively, and therefore it was deemed necessary to deeply examine the issue of the description of the military tales. Through a comparative review of the military tales between the works, it can be confirmed that in the process of retelling the narrative of the previous work, &lt;Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok&gt; expanded and mutated the content corresponding to the military tale, that the military tales, which total 19 times including the previous work, were differentiated from each other through variations in the form of antagonistic characters and the method of confrontation, and that while the activities of the characters corresponding to the direct line of the Um clan were abbreviated or omitted, the activities of the characters of the other clan (他門) who are relatives were specified, weakening the narrative centered on the single clan(一門). Based on the above points, it can be confirmed that the military tales of the three works including &lt;Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok&gt; and &lt;Yunhajeongsammunchwirok&gt; were created with careful consideration for the readers’ ‘continued reading’ of the three works and the heightened interest unique to military tales. In addition, it was inferred that while military tales can be sufficiently attractive stories in the enjoyment of Korean long novels, they can also be factors that divide opinions or reduce interest depending on the reader’s taste and creative style. Finally, considering that the military tales in the work show the direction of strengthening the interrelationship and continuous reading among the three works and the weakening of the narrative centered on one sentence, it was revealed that it is more appropriate to define &lt;Umssihyomuncheonghaengrok&gt; as a trilogy of novels that follows &lt;Yunhajeongsammunchwirok&gt; and &lt;Yunhajeongsammunchwirok&gt;.

Vol. 69
Openalex Percentile: Top 84%
Japanese History and Culture
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.