Understanding Miracles in Ashʿarī Theology

Drawing on a range of scholars from the Ashʿarī tradition, this article offers a systematic presentation of their understanding of miracles, beginning with the general metaphysical principles such as God’s omnipotence, occasionalism, and the contingent nature of creation. From this metaphysical foundation, the article explores the seven types of miracles recognized within the Ashʿarī tradition: (1) prophetic miracles (muʿjizāt), (2) pre-prophetic indicators (irhāṣ), (3) divine graces (karāmāt), (4) miraculous aid (maʿūna), (5) divine debasement (istidrāj), (6) debasement of false claimants (ihāna), and (7) black magic (siḥr). Given the variety of miraculous phenomena, the need to clearly distinguish prophetic miracles from other types becomes essential for validating prophetic authority. To address this, the article focuses on three key conditions—(C1) a break of custom (kharq li-l-ʿāda), (C2) a claim to prophethood (taḥaddī), and (C3) an unmet challenge (sālim min al-muʿāraḍa)—which collectively affirm the authenticity and uniqueness of prophetic miracles within the Ashʿarī framework. By clarifying these distinctions, the article contributes to a comprehensive understanding of miracles and prophetic authority in Ashʿarī theology.