The Importance of Being Onset: Tuscan Lenition and Stops in Coda Position

This paper examines Gorgia Toscana (GT), a phenomenon of stop lenition observed in Tuscan varieties of Italian. Traditionally, this process has been understood to occur in post-vocalic positions, which, in the native lexicon, corresponds to onset position due to the absence of stops in syllable codas in Italian, apart from geminate consonants that straddle the coda and onset of adjacent syllables. However, stops in coda positions are found in both loanwords (e.g., admin, Batman) and bookwords (e.g., ritmo, tecnica). Drawing on original acoustic data collected from 42 native speakers of Florentine Italian, we investigated the realization of stops in such lexical items through allophonic classification and quantitative analysis. Our primary aim was to test the Onset Hypothesis, which posits that Gorgia exclusively affects stops in onset positions, implying that coda stops should not undergo lenition. Our findings support this hypothesis. We provide a phonological analysis within the frameworks of Strict CV and Coda Mirror, emphasizing the importance of syllable structure in understanding the manifestation of Gorgia Toscana, which we argue cannot be adequately captured solely by considering the linear order of segments.