Leveraging high variant allele frequencies (VAF) of DNA damage repair (DDR) mutations (muts) in liquid biopsy (LBx) as a surrogate for germline testing: Implications for precision medicine.

10576 Background: LBx based next-generation sequencing (NGS) provides a minimally invasive means to detect true DDR muts as well as DDR muts that represent clonal hematopoiesis of indeterminate potential (CHIP), and in certain cases identifying high VAF DDR muts of suspected germline origin. Herein, we aim to address the knowledge gap in interpreting these findings to guide germline testing. Methods: We retrospectively collected data on patients (pts) with cancer who underwent LBx with FoundationOneLiquid CDx (311 gene panel) from 2022-2024 and tissue biopsy (TBx) based NGS using either Caris Life Sciences or FoundationOne CDx. A panel of 22 muts directly involved in the DDR pathway were designated as DDR muts. Findings from LBx and TBx were reported using descriptive statistics. Best objective clinical responses were evaluated using RECIST v1.1. Results: The study cohort consisted of 637 pts tested using LBx, with the majority being male (62.6%; n=399) and white (81%; n=517). On LBx, 203 pts (31.8%; n=203/637) were identified to have one or more DDR muts. Paired testing with LBx and Tbx was available for 221 pts of which 28 pts (12.6%) had ‘true CHIP’ (identified on LBx but not on TBx), all contributed by ATM and CHEK2 (50% each; n=14/28). Of pts who had paired LBx and TBx (n=221), 24 pts (10.8%) had the same DDR mut on both, suggesting likely somatic origin (True DDRs), the most common being ATM (25%; n=6/24), PALB2 (12.5%; n=3/24) and CDK12 (12.5%; n=3/24). Using a linear mixed-effects model to account for patient- and gene-level variability in VAF, true DDRs had a significantly (p < 0.001) higher VAF (median: 46.8, IQR: 49.6, n = 26) compared to true CHIP DDRs (median: 0.24, IQR: 0.29, n = 31). LBx revealed potential germline implications based on high VAF in 7.9% pts (n=50/637) of which 45 pts had DDR muts. Genetic referrals were initiated in 48% (n=24/50) with subsequent confirmatory germline testing done for 66.6% (n=16/24), all confirming germline muts (table 1). Notably, for the 52% (n=26/50) without genetic referrals, 73% (n=19/26) lacked documentation of a referral discussion. Out of the 50 pts with muts likely of germline origin, 19 were enrolled in phase-1 clinical trials, with 6 receiving matched therapies targeting DDR muts (PARP and ATR inhibitors). Of these, 1 had a partial response (CHEK2) and 3 had stable disease (1-MUTYH, 2-PALB2). Conclusions: LBx can be used as a potential surrogate indicator of likely germline muts as evidenced by high VAFs. Our findings underscore the need for improved interpretation of LBx reports to guide timely genetic referrals and confirmatory germline testing. Gene Median VAF (IQR) BAP1 (n=1) 52.4% (52.4-52.4) MUTYH (n=2) 51.3% (50.7–51.9) CHEK2 (n=2) 51.0% (50–52) ATM (n=2) 50.2% (49.8–50.6) BRCA2 (n=4) 50.0% (48.5–52.2) PALB2 (n=2) 48.4% (46.7–50.2) MSH6 (n=1) 46.6% (46.6-46.6)

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Clinical Oncology
Published
2025-05-28
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1200/jco.2025.43.16_suppl.10576
Primary Topic
Cancer Genomics and Diagnostics
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Leveraging high variant allele frequencies (VAF) of DNA damage repair (DDR) mutations (muts) in liquid biopsy (LBx) as a surrogate for germline testing: Implications for precision medicine.

Minh Phan, Hassan Abushukair, Charles W. Caldwell, Susanna Varkey Ulahannan et al.
Journal of Clinical Oncology
Cancer Genomics and Diagnostics
article

Leveraging high variant allele frequencies (VAF) of DNA damage repair (DDR) mutations (muts) in liquid biopsy (LBx) as a surrogate for germline testing: Implications for precision medicine.

Minh Phan, Hassan Abushukair, Charles W. Caldwell, Susanna Varkey Ulahannan, Nirmal Choradia, Kathleen N. Moore, Max Bouvette, Adanma Ayanambakkam, Naoko Takebe, Jackson Roberts, Abdul Rafeh Naqash, Debra L. Richardson, Niveditha Popuri, Arifa Bibi, Raid Aljumaily, Ayesha Aijaz, Sagal Pannu, Trey Gradnigo
article en

Abstract

10576 Background: LBx based next-generation sequencing (NGS) provides a minimally invasive means to detect true DDR muts as well as DDR muts that represent clonal hematopoiesis of indeterminate potential (CHIP), and in certain cases identifying high VAF DDR muts of suspected germline origin. Herein, we aim to address the knowledge gap in interpreting these findings to guide germline testing. Methods: We retrospectively collected data on patients (pts) with cancer who underwent LBx with FoundationOneLiquid CDx (311 gene panel) from 2022-2024 and tissue biopsy (TBx) based NGS using either Caris Life Sciences or FoundationOne CDx. A panel of 22 muts directly involved in the DDR pathway were designated as DDR muts. Findings from LBx and TBx were reported using descriptive statistics. Best objective clinical responses were evaluated using RECIST v1.1. Results: The study cohort consisted of 637 pts tested using LBx, with the majority being male (62.6%; n=399) and white (81%; n=517). On LBx, 203 pts (31.8%; n=203/637) were identified to have one or more DDR muts. Paired testing with LBx and Tbx was available for 221 pts of which 28 pts (12.6%) had ‘true CHIP’ (identified on LBx but not on TBx), all contributed by ATM and CHEK2 (50% each; n=14/28). Of pts who had paired LBx and TBx (n=221), 24 pts (10.8%) had the same DDR mut on both, suggesting likely somatic origin (True DDRs), the most common being ATM (25%; n=6/24), PALB2 (12.5%; n=3/24) and CDK12 (12.5%; n=3/24). Using a linear mixed-effects model to account for patient- and gene-level variability in VAF, true DDRs had a significantly (p < 0.001) higher VAF (median: 46.8, IQR: 49.6, n = 26) compared to true CHIP DDRs (median: 0.24, IQR: 0.29, n = 31). LBx revealed potential germline implications based on high VAF in 7.9% pts (n=50/637) of which 45 pts had DDR muts. Genetic referrals were initiated in 48% (n=24/50) with subsequent confirmatory germline testing done for 66.6% (n=16/24), all confirming germline muts (table 1). Notably, for the 52% (n=26/50) without genetic referrals, 73% (n=19/26) lacked documentation of a referral discussion. Out of the 50 pts with muts likely of germline origin, 19 were enrolled in phase-1 clinical trials, with 6 receiving matched therapies targeting DDR muts (PARP and ATR inhibitors). Of these, 1 had a partial response (CHEK2) and 3 had stable disease (1-MUTYH, 2-PALB2). Conclusions: LBx can be used as a potential surrogate indicator of likely germline muts as evidenced by high VAFs. Our findings underscore the need for improved interpretation of LBx reports to guide timely genetic referrals and confirmatory germline testing. Gene Median VAF (IQR) BAP1 (n=1) 52.4% (52.4-52.4) MUTYH (n=2) 51.3% (50.7–51.9) CHEK2 (n=2) 51.0% (50–52) ATM (n=2) 50.2% (49.8–50.6) BRCA2 (n=4) 50.0% (48.5–52.2) PALB2 (n=2) 48.4% (46.7–50.2) MSH6 (n=1) 46.6% (46.6-46.6)

Journal of Clinical OncologyVol. 43(16_suppl)
University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center (US), University of Oklahoma (US)
Openalex Percentile: Top 83%
Cancer Genomics and Diagnostics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.