Evaluation and application of the CROPGRO – Cowpea model for simulating appropriate sowing window and planting density of cowpea varieties across contrasting environments

Cowpea [ Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp.] is an important legume crop in sub-Saharan Africa where its grain and fodder are valued for food and feed. Grain yields are, however, low due to several biotic and abiotic constraints. Several improved stress-tolerant varieties and complementary agronomic management technologies have been developed to enhance its productivity and sustainability. Cropping simulation models are useful tools for evaluating the deployment of crop varieties and management options for target locations. While the CSM-CROPGRO model in DSSAT has been used to simulate the performance of several legume crops, only a few studies have evaluated and used the relatively new CSM-CROPGRO-cowpea model for use in West Africa. The objectives of this study were to (i) evaluate the performance of the CSM-CROPGRO-Cowpea model in simulating the cowpea growth and yields in contrasting environments (ii) use the model to assess the optimal sowing window and planting density of cowpea varieties across contrasting environments in the savannas of Nigeria. Here, we used comprehensive savanna-wide datasets to calibrate and validate the CSM-CROPGRO-cowpea model for savannah environments. The evaluated model was then applied to assess the yield performance of cowpea varieties with varying plant densities and six sowing windows across four sites considering 36 growing seasons. The model accurately simulated cowpea phenology (RMSE 0.58–0.67 day; nRMSE 1.36–1.46 %; d-index > 0.90 for days to flowering, RMSE 0.82–1.73 days; nRMSE 1.09–2.29 %; d-index 0.88–0.99 for days to physiological maturity), grain yield (RMSE 86–121 kg ha −1 ; nRMSE 3.66–6.14 %; d-index > 0.90) and total dry matter (RMSE 260–295 kg ha −1 ; nRMSE 4.79–10.73 %; d-index = 0.87–0.95). The long-term simulation results indicate that SAMPEA 9 showed no response to sowing density beyond 13.3 plants m –2 across all locations, likely due to interplant competition at higher densities. In contrast, the simulated yield of SAMPEA 14 and FUAMPEA 1 increased as plant density increases from 13.3 to 40 plants m⁻². In northern Guinea savanna, sowing could be delayed until July 14 at Demsa and July 29 at Zaria for all tested varieties. In the Sudan savanna AEZ (SS), sowing should be done between July 1 and 14 for all varieties, beyond which there will be a significant reduction in yield. Except for SAMPEA 9, the simulated optimum planting density for all the varieties is 40 plants m –2 in all AEZ, while the sowing window was dependent on location and AEZ. The variety SAMPEA 9 was the most yield-stable variety across the tested environments and did not require planting density above the current industry recommendations of 13.3 plants m −2 . This study could fill the knowledge gap in understanding optimal cowpea management opportunities needed to maximize productivity and strengthen cropping resilience.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Field Crops Research
Published
2025-05-23
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fcr.2025.109988
Primary Topic
Climate change impacts on agriculture
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Evaluation and application of the CROPGRO – Cowpea model for simulating appropriate sowing window and planting density of cowpea varieties across contrasting environments

Jenneh F. Bebeley, Abdullahi I. Tofa, Kamaluddin T. Aliyu, Jibrin Mohammed Jibrin et al.
Field Crops Research
Climate change impacts on agriculture
article

Evaluation and application of the CROPGRO – Cowpea model for simulating appropriate sowing window and planting density of cowpea varieties across contrasting environments

Jenneh F. Bebeley, Abdullahi I. Tofa, Kamaluddin T. Aliyu, Jibrin Mohammed Jibrin, Ismail Ibrahim Garba, Alpha Y. Kamara, Reuben Solomon, Lucky O. Omoigui, Osagie B. Eseigbe, Musibau A. Adeleke, Helen P. Jerome
article en

Abstract

Cowpea [ Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp.] is an important legume crop in sub-Saharan Africa where its grain and fodder are valued for food and feed. Grain yields are, however, low due to several biotic and abiotic constraints. Several improved stress-tolerant varieties and complementary agronomic management technologies have been developed to enhance its productivity and sustainability. Cropping simulation models are useful tools for evaluating the deployment of crop varieties and management options for target locations. While the CSM-CROPGRO model in DSSAT has been used to simulate the performance of several legume crops, only a few studies have evaluated and used the relatively new CSM-CROPGRO-cowpea model for use in West Africa. The objectives of this study were to (i) evaluate the performance of the CSM-CROPGRO-Cowpea model in simulating the cowpea growth and yields in contrasting environments (ii) use the model to assess the optimal sowing window and planting density of cowpea varieties across contrasting environments in the savannas of Nigeria. Here, we used comprehensive savanna-wide datasets to calibrate and validate the CSM-CROPGRO-cowpea model for savannah environments. The evaluated model was then applied to assess the yield performance of cowpea varieties with varying plant densities and six sowing windows across four sites considering 36 growing seasons. The model accurately simulated cowpea phenology (RMSE 0.58–0.67 day; nRMSE 1.36–1.46 %; d-index > 0.90 for days to flowering, RMSE 0.82–1.73 days; nRMSE 1.09–2.29 %; d-index 0.88–0.99 for days to physiological maturity), grain yield (RMSE 86–121 kg ha −1 ; nRMSE 3.66–6.14 %; d-index > 0.90) and total dry matter (RMSE 260–295 kg ha −1 ; nRMSE 4.79–10.73 %; d-index = 0.87–0.95). The long-term simulation results indicate that SAMPEA 9 showed no response to sowing density beyond 13.3 plants m –2 across all locations, likely due to interplant competition at higher densities. In contrast, the simulated yield of SAMPEA 14 and FUAMPEA 1 increased as plant density increases from 13.3 to 40 plants m⁻². In northern Guinea savanna, sowing could be delayed until July 14 at Demsa and July 29 at Zaria for all tested varieties. In the Sudan savanna AEZ (SS), sowing should be done between July 1 and 14 for all varieties, beyond which there will be a significant reduction in yield. Except for SAMPEA 9, the simulated optimum planting density for all the varieties is 40 plants m –2 in all AEZ, while the sowing window was dependent on location and AEZ. The variety SAMPEA 9 was the most yield-stable variety across the tested environments and did not require planting density above the current industry recommendations of 13.3 plants m −2 . This study could fill the knowledge gap in understanding optimal cowpea management opportunities needed to maximize productivity and strengthen cropping resilience.

Field Crops ResearchVol. 331
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (AU), International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (NG), Agriculture and Food (AU), Bayero University Kano (NG)
Zero hunger
Openalex Percentile: Top 91%
Climate change impacts on agriculture
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.