Post-wildfire assessment and fire resilience strategies: a case study from Turkiye, with a critical evaluation of NRC-2021

Purpose The purpose of this study is to assess structural damage mechanisms and evaluate fire resilience strategies following the 2021 Manavgat wildfire in Turkiye. Through detailed on-site inspections of 210 damaged structures, the research critically compares observed damage with recommendations from the National Guide for Wildland–Urban Interface Fires (NRC-2021), highlighting practical challenges, regional adaptability, economic feasibility and policy integration. The study provides targeted recommendations to enhance building resilience, improve wildfire mitigation strategies and inform future building codes, aiming ultimately to safeguard communities from similar wildfire incidents. Design/methodology/approach The study employed a detailed on-site investigation of 210 wildfire-affected buildings in Manavgat, Turkiye, including masonry, reinforced concrete (RC), steel and mixed structures. Structural damage and failure mechanisms were systematically identified, documented and categorized based on severity and construction materials. Observations from site inspections were then critically compared with the Canadian National Guide for Wildland–Urban Interface Fires (NRC-2021), assessing compliance levels, highlighting gaps and evaluating the effectiveness, practicality and adaptability of recommended resilience strategies to regional conditions. Findings The study identified that structural failures following the wildfire were primarily due to inadequate fire resilience measures, with timber components highly vulnerable to ignition, RC experiencing significant spalling and steel structures prone to rapid strength loss and buckling. Comparative analysis showed low compliance rates with NRC-2021 guidelines, especially concerning external walls, roofs, doors and windows. Results highlighted practical implementation challenges, economic limitations and gaps in regional adaptability, underscoring the critical need for comprehensive integration of fire-resistant construction strategies, effective vegetation management, regular maintenance and improved community-level preparedness planning. Originality/value This study offers original insights by providing a comprehensive field-based assessment of structural damage and resilience strategies from a major wildfire incident in Turkiye, critically benchmarking observed outcomes against the NRC-2021 guidelines. Its uniqueness lies in systematically evaluating implementation challenges, economic constraints, regional adaptability and policy integration gaps. The research contributes valuable, evidence-based recommendations to enhance fire-resilient construction, improve existing standards and inform future wildfire management policies, benefiting parties involved in disaster risk reduction, emergency planning and sustainable urban development.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
Published
2025-05-22
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1108/jsfe-08-2024-0032
Primary Topic
Fire effects on ecosystems
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Post-wildfire assessment and fire resilience strategies: a case study from Turkiye, with a critical evaluation of NRC-2021

Mehmet Şentürk, Hamid Farrokh Ghatte, Aslan Soyer
2 links
Journal of Structural Fire Engineering
Fire effects on ecosystems
article

Post-wildfire assessment and fire resilience strategies: a case study from Turkiye, with a critical evaluation of NRC-2021

Mehmet Şentürk, Hamid Farrokh Ghatte, Aslan Soyer
article en

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this study is to assess structural damage mechanisms and evaluate fire resilience strategies following the 2021 Manavgat wildfire in Turkiye. Through detailed on-site inspections of 210 damaged structures, the research critically compares observed damage with recommendations from the National Guide for Wildland–Urban Interface Fires (NRC-2021), highlighting practical challenges, regional adaptability, economic feasibility and policy integration. The study provides targeted recommendations to enhance building resilience, improve wildfire mitigation strategies and inform future building codes, aiming ultimately to safeguard communities from similar wildfire incidents. Design/methodology/approach The study employed a detailed on-site investigation of 210 wildfire-affected buildings in Manavgat, Turkiye, including masonry, reinforced concrete (RC), steel and mixed structures. Structural damage and failure mechanisms were systematically identified, documented and categorized based on severity and construction materials. Observations from site inspections were then critically compared with the Canadian National Guide for Wildland–Urban Interface Fires (NRC-2021), assessing compliance levels, highlighting gaps and evaluating the effectiveness, practicality and adaptability of recommended resilience strategies to regional conditions. Findings The study identified that structural failures following the wildfire were primarily due to inadequate fire resilience measures, with timber components highly vulnerable to ignition, RC experiencing significant spalling and steel structures prone to rapid strength loss and buckling. Comparative analysis showed low compliance rates with NRC-2021 guidelines, especially concerning external walls, roofs, doors and windows. Results highlighted practical implementation challenges, economic limitations and gaps in regional adaptability, underscoring the critical need for comprehensive integration of fire-resistant construction strategies, effective vegetation management, regular maintenance and improved community-level preparedness planning. Originality/value This study offers original insights by providing a comprehensive field-based assessment of structural damage and resilience strategies from a major wildfire incident in Turkiye, critically benchmarking observed outcomes against the NRC-2021 guidelines. Its uniqueness lies in systematically evaluating implementation challenges, economic constraints, regional adaptability and policy integration gaps. The research contributes valuable, evidence-based recommendations to enhance fire-resilient construction, improve existing standards and inform future wildfire management policies, benefiting parties involved in disaster risk reduction, emergency planning and sustainable urban development.

Journal of Structural Fire EngineeringVol. 16(3)
Antalya Bilim University (TR), Coventry University (GB)
Openalex Percentile: Top 89%
Fire effects on ecosystems
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.