Metal Matrix Composite Coatings Deposited by Laser Cladding: On the Effectiveness of WC Reinforcement for Wear Resistance and Its Synergy with the Matrix Material (Ni Versus Co Alloys)

This work investigates the effect of the addition of tungsten carbide (WC) particles as reinforcements to Ni (Inconel 625) versus Co (Stellite 6) alloys during deposition by laser cladding to form wear-resistant metal matrix composite (MMC) coatings. While the related literature often associates the presence of WC with the enhanced wear performance of MMC coatings, this work shows that such an effect is not universal as it may critically depend on the metallic matrix employed. Thus, to demonstrate whether the reinforcement and matrix act synergically in such a scenario or not, MMC coatings formed by Inconel 625 and Stellite 6, both with WC content ranging from 10% to 40%, were deposited under the same laser cladding setup on AISI 304 stainless steel substrates, being WC-free samples produced together for comparison basis. As expected, the hardness levels increased with more WC presence in both matrices, but the wear resistance was specifically evaluated by means of the metal wheel abrasion test (ASTM B611). The results revealed that the use of WC as a reinforcement indeed affects the matrix materials differently; for Stellite 6, the wear resistance increased with up to 20% of WC (in contrast to the hardness indication), whereas for Inconel 625, the wear resistance progressively decreased with more WC content. It was observed via scanning electron microscopy (SEM) that the WC particles within the Inconel 625 alloy tended to intensive cracking, being in this way more prone to detach from the matrix and hence representing a weakening factor for the effectiveness of the coatings produced. Thus, it is concluded that the addition of WC particles, as potential reinforcements for MMC coatings, is not always effective (synergic with the matrix) in providing wear resistance, hence, opposing the prevailing consensus. This outcome and its reasons will certainly help with insights into proper design of MMC coatings, starting with the importance of matrix material selection.