A non-invasive archaeometric protocol for characterizing possible Corallium rubrum-related carbonate materials in decorations on Iron Age bronze fibulae of the Golasecca culture

• A non-invasive protocol to study coral-related insets on ancient fibulae is presented. • 46 Iron Age bronze fibulae with alleged coral decorations from Italy were studied. • Polyenes, high-Mg-calcite or typical micro-morphologies account for coral identification. • CaCO 3 with low or no Mg was also found, likely resulting from coral meteoric diagenesis. • Technological choices influenced the metal alloy composition in different artefacts. In the Iron Age, the Golasecca culture in Northwestern Italy connected Italic populations with transalpine and Celtic ones. From the 7th century BCE, in some jewellery artefacts (bronze fibulae and pendants) a whitish material constituting either part of the objects or nestled decorations is observed. Archaeologists identify it as coral ( Corallium rubrum ), its red hue whitened by the passing of time. However, few archaeometric studies have been carried out so far, also because of their invasiveness. 46 artefacts with whitish decorations from the archaeological sites of Como, Castelletto Ticino and Golasecca (stored in the Museo Civico Archeologico ‘P. Giovio’, in Como) are investigated here with a novel, non-destructive, multi-analytical protocol (i.e., μ-Raman spectroscopy, μ-X-ray diffraction, optical microscopy and SEM-EDS in low-vacuum), which completely safeguards their integrity. This approach, applied on the artefacts as such, allows identifying their constituent materials and degradation byproducts, extrapolating information about their nature, history and manufacturing process. Ca-carbonates – in the form of calcite – are identified in the decorations of most studied artefacts. This evidence alone does not account for their biologic origin (i.e., from C. rubrum ), but other aspects can help in solving such an issue. In several artefacts, high-Mg calcite (HMC, a marker for biogenic carbonates) + polyenes (the typical pigments of red coral), sole HMC or even a mixture of HMC + LMC are identified – often coupled to typical coral micro-morphologies. A biogenic origin for these carbonates (i.e. red coral, though other similar species cannot be completely ruled out) can certainly be ascertained – lack of polyenes being justified by possible denaturation over time. In other artefacts, however, low-Mg-calcite (LMC) or even pure-calcite (i.e., with no detectable Mg) are found with no polyenes – hinting a possible inorganic origin. Most of these, however, show typical coral micro-morphologies. In these decorations, Mg-depletion might thus depend on the meteoric diagenesis of originally biogenic carbonates, responsible for transformation of HMC to LMC (or even pure-calcite) and decay of polyenes. Other materials are also seldom detected – i.e., gypsum, probably resulting from sulfation of an original coralline matrix interred in acidic soils, and Ca-phosphates, due to sporadic use of bones. All these evidences point to the fact that C. rubrum was feasibly used in at least ≈ 70 % of the studied decorated artefacts. For what concerns the composition of the alloy, bronze or lead-bronze can be found in different artefacts – or even different portions of the same item – possibly depending on sharp technological issues, dictated by fluidity or workability during manufacture.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Archaeological Science Reports
Published
2025-04-14
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jasrep.2025.105131
Primary Topic
Maritime and Coastal Archaeology
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

A non-invasive archaeometric protocol for characterizing possible Corallium rubrum-related carbonate materials in decorations on Iron Age bronze fibulae of the Golasecca culture

Giulia Berruto, Roberto Giustetto, Eliano Diana
Journal of Archaeological Science Reports
Maritime and Coastal Archaeology
article

A non-invasive archaeometric protocol for characterizing possible Corallium rubrum-related carbonate materials in decorations on Iron Age bronze fibulae of the Golasecca culture

Giulia Berruto, Roberto Giustetto, Eliano Diana
article en

Abstract

• A non-invasive protocol to study coral-related insets on ancient fibulae is presented. • 46 Iron Age bronze fibulae with alleged coral decorations from Italy were studied. • Polyenes, high-Mg-calcite or typical micro-morphologies account for coral identification. • CaCO 3 with low or no Mg was also found, likely resulting from coral meteoric diagenesis. • Technological choices influenced the metal alloy composition in different artefacts. In the Iron Age, the Golasecca culture in Northwestern Italy connected Italic populations with transalpine and Celtic ones. From the 7th century BCE, in some jewellery artefacts (bronze fibulae and pendants) a whitish material constituting either part of the objects or nestled decorations is observed. Archaeologists identify it as coral ( Corallium rubrum ), its red hue whitened by the passing of time. However, few archaeometric studies have been carried out so far, also because of their invasiveness. 46 artefacts with whitish decorations from the archaeological sites of Como, Castelletto Ticino and Golasecca (stored in the Museo Civico Archeologico ‘P. Giovio’, in Como) are investigated here with a novel, non-destructive, multi-analytical protocol (i.e., μ-Raman spectroscopy, μ-X-ray diffraction, optical microscopy and SEM-EDS in low-vacuum), which completely safeguards their integrity. This approach, applied on the artefacts as such, allows identifying their constituent materials and degradation byproducts, extrapolating information about their nature, history and manufacturing process. Ca-carbonates – in the form of calcite – are identified in the decorations of most studied artefacts. This evidence alone does not account for their biologic origin (i.e., from C. rubrum ), but other aspects can help in solving such an issue. In several artefacts, high-Mg calcite (HMC, a marker for biogenic carbonates) + polyenes (the typical pigments of red coral), sole HMC or even a mixture of HMC + LMC are identified – often coupled to typical coral micro-morphologies. A biogenic origin for these carbonates (i.e. red coral, though other similar species cannot be completely ruled out) can certainly be ascertained – lack of polyenes being justified by possible denaturation over time. In other artefacts, however, low-Mg-calcite (LMC) or even pure-calcite (i.e., with no detectable Mg) are found with no polyenes – hinting a possible inorganic origin. Most of these, however, show typical coral micro-morphologies. In these decorations, Mg-depletion might thus depend on the meteoric diagenesis of originally biogenic carbonates, responsible for transformation of HMC to LMC (or even pure-calcite) and decay of polyenes. Other materials are also seldom detected – i.e., gypsum, probably resulting from sulfation of an original coralline matrix interred in acidic soils, and Ca-phosphates, due to sporadic use of bones. All these evidences point to the fact that C. rubrum was feasibly used in at least ≈ 70 % of the studied decorated artefacts. For what concerns the composition of the alloy, bronze or lead-bronze can be found in different artefacts – or even different portions of the same item – possibly depending on sharp technological issues, dictated by fluidity or workability during manufacture.

Journal of Archaeological Science ReportsVol. 64
Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, Sezione di Torino (IT), Nanomaterials Research (United States) (US), University of Turin (IT)
Life below water
Openalex Percentile: Top 90%
Maritime and Coastal Archaeology
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.