Retained Tree Biomass Rather than Replanted One Determines Soil Fertility in Early Stand Reconstruction in Chinese Fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata) Plantations

Soil nutrient and fertility assessments provide a direct measure for evaluating forest management effects. In this study, we examined soil nutrient content in Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata) plantations under four reconstruction patterns: pure plantation, introduced broadleaf, introduced needleleaf, and introduced mixed broadleaf-needleleaf. The soil fertility index (SFI) evaluation model was constructed based on partial least squares path modeling (PLS-PM), revealing the influence of stand characteristics on SFI in early stand reconstruction. The results showed that, compared to pure plantations, total nutrient content increased in the introduced needleleaf pattern by 13.94% to 21.15% and available nutrient content by 18.21% to 26.91%. In contrast, both introduced broadleaf and mixed broadleaf-needleleaf exhibited a declining trend. Significant differences were observed among the reconstruction patterns (p < 0.05). In the SFI evaluation model, soil chemistry total nutrient (SCT) and soil chemistry available nutrient (SCA) made significant contributions. The weights of SCT and SCA in SFI were 0.52 and 0.48, respectively. The SFI of four patterns ranged from 0.43 to 0.58, indicating relatively low soil fertility. Compared to pure plantations, introduced trees did not enhance soil fertility in early stand reconstruction. The SFI of the introduced needleleaf was significantly higher than that of the other two reconstruction patterns (p < 0.05). Stand construction (including diameter at breast height, tree density, and tree biomass) explained 14.69% of SFI variation, with a contribution of 31.72% in the surface soil layer (0~20 cm). Tree biomass significantly influenced SFI variation, accounting for over 40% of the total stand factors. Retained tree biomass had a substantially greater effect than introduced tree biomass, contributing twice as much to SFI variation. PLS-PM could effectively reflect the soil nutrient status and accurately estimate the weight of soil fertility. In early stand reconstruction, retained tree biomass might be the major influence on soil fertility variation. We suggest determining reasonable thinning intensity to retain enough Chinese fir and promote the growth of introduced trees. This study introduces a novel approach to soil fertility assessment and provides theoretical support for formulating effective forest management strategies in the early reconstruction of Chinese fir plantations.