Single-Molecule Fluorescence Microscopy Reveals Energy Transfer Active versus Inactive Nanocrystal/Dye Conjugate Pairs

Defect-mediated energy transfer (EnT) is a radiative process that occurs between donor defect states in the forbidden bandgap of semiconductor nanocrystals (NCs) and dye molecules bound to their surfaces. The EnT efficiency depends on the number of dye molecules attached to each NC, the donor-acceptor distance, and the dipole orientation factor between the donor and acceptor, all of which vary across <i>all</i> individual NCs in a sample. While ensemble-level fluorescence spectroscopy measurements have provided <i>average</i> values for donor-acceptor distances, dye-to-NC ratios, and EnT rate constants, questions remain about the impact of donor/acceptor heterogeneity on observed EnT efficiencies. Notably, ensemble-level measurements cannot distinguish between bare NCs and EnT-active versus inactive NC/dye pairs in the same sample batch, limiting the ability to design systems with 100% EnT efficiency. To address this, we studied defect-mediated EnT between AlexaFluor 555 dye acceptors chemically bound to ZnO NC donors at the level of single molecules and single NCs. Interestingly, 20% of bound NC/dye pairs are EnT-inactive, likely contributing to residual defect photoluminescence (PL) observed in ensemble-level measurements and reducing overall EnT efficiency. Single particle-level ZnO defect PL and acceptor fluorescence trajectories exhibited distinct microfluctuations, which are absent in bare ZnO NCs. We hypothesized that our observations can be explained with a competitive dye fluorescence quenching pathway, possibly due to charge transfer between the excited state dye and the ZnO NC. Numerical simulations of single-molecule PL traces for this scenario produced microfluctuations consistent with the experimental results. These findings highlight the impact of sample heterogeneity on EnT processes and provide insights for designing light-harvesting systems with optimized EnT efficiency.