Non-condensable gas accumulation and distribution due to condensation in the CIGMA facility: Implications for Fukushima Daiichi Unit 3 (1F3)

This study was motivated by previous analysis by TEPSYS, which indicated that different temperatures in the 5th and 4th floors of the reactor building (R/B) of Fukushima Daiichi Unit 3 (1F3) could significantly influence the distribution of non-condensable gases during the severe accident in 2011. Understanding this effect is crucial for assessing the risks associated with non-condensable gas accumulation in R/B, particularly considering that the hydrogen explosion in 1F3 may not have been a single-stage event but could have involved a multi-stage explosion. To investigate the distribution and transport on non-condensable gas under varying cooling conditions, an experimental study was conducted using the CIGMA facility, a large-scale test vessel with segmented sections created by partition plates, designed to replicate the structure and conditions of the R/B. Steam and helium, used as non-condensable hydrogen substituted, were continuously injected at the top of the CIGMA vessel for 10,000 s to replicate the leakage of steam and hydrogen through the shield plug. Two cooling conditions were tested: Case 1 with a cooling temperature of 50 °C, and Case 2 with a cooling temperature of 90 °C. The experiments aimed to explore how varying cooling temperatures impact helium accumulation in different regions of the R/B structure. The study found that in both cases, the highest concentration of non-condensable gases may not always be near the injection point but rather in downstream regions. In these regions, steam and non-condensable gases move downward and continue to condense, significantly enhancing the concentration of helium. Specifically, in Case 1, after 10,000 s, the helium concentration reached 65 % in the middle region (representing the 4th floor of R/B) and 45 % in the top region (representing the 5th floor of R/B). Analysis using the Shapiro ternary diagram showed that, under these conditions, the gas mixture in the middle region posed a potential detonation risk. This study provides important insights into gas distribution within a nuclear reactor building during severe accident conditions, which are crucial for developing more effective safety measures and risk mitigation strategies in nuclear reactor designs. • Experimental study on helium accumulation and distribution in the CIGMA facility, simulating Fukushima Daiichi Unit 3 conditions. • Investigated how varying cooling temperatures affect steam condensation and non-condensable gas accumulation. • The highest helium concentrations were found in regions downstream of the injection point, where steam continues to condense. • The Shapiro ternary diagram showed a potential detonation risk in regions lower than injection point. • Findings provide critical insights into gas distribution patterns in reactor building during severe accident conditions.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Progress in Nuclear Energy
Published
2025-04-03
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pnucene.2025.105771
Citations
3
Primary Topic
Nuclear Physics and Applications
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
5.65
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Non-condensable gas accumulation and distribution due to condensation in the CIGMA facility: Implications for Fukushima Daiichi Unit 3 (1F3)

Shu Soma, Yasuteru Sibamoto, Ari Hamdani, Satoshi Abe
3 citations
Progress in Nuclear Energy
Nuclear Physics and Applications
5.65
article

Non-condensable gas accumulation and distribution due to condensation in the CIGMA facility: Implications for Fukushima Daiichi Unit 3 (1F3)

Shu Soma, Yasuteru Sibamoto, Ari Hamdani, Satoshi Abe
article en
3 citations

Abstract

This study was motivated by previous analysis by TEPSYS, which indicated that different temperatures in the 5th and 4th floors of the reactor building (R/B) of Fukushima Daiichi Unit 3 (1F3) could significantly influence the distribution of non-condensable gases during the severe accident in 2011. Understanding this effect is crucial for assessing the risks associated with non-condensable gas accumulation in R/B, particularly considering that the hydrogen explosion in 1F3 may not have been a single-stage event but could have involved a multi-stage explosion. To investigate the distribution and transport on non-condensable gas under varying cooling conditions, an experimental study was conducted using the CIGMA facility, a large-scale test vessel with segmented sections created by partition plates, designed to replicate the structure and conditions of the R/B. Steam and helium, used as non-condensable hydrogen substituted, were continuously injected at the top of the CIGMA vessel for 10,000 s to replicate the leakage of steam and hydrogen through the shield plug. Two cooling conditions were tested: Case 1 with a cooling temperature of 50 °C, and Case 2 with a cooling temperature of 90 °C. The experiments aimed to explore how varying cooling temperatures impact helium accumulation in different regions of the R/B structure. The study found that in both cases, the highest concentration of non-condensable gases may not always be near the injection point but rather in downstream regions. In these regions, steam and non-condensable gases move downward and continue to condense, significantly enhancing the concentration of helium. Specifically, in Case 1, after 10,000 s, the helium concentration reached 65 % in the middle region (representing the 4th floor of R/B) and 45 % in the top region (representing the 5th floor of R/B). Analysis using the Shapiro ternary diagram showed that, under these conditions, the gas mixture in the middle region posed a potential detonation risk. This study provides important insights into gas distribution within a nuclear reactor building during severe accident conditions, which are crucial for developing more effective safety measures and risk mitigation strategies in nuclear reactor designs. • Experimental study on helium accumulation and distribution in the CIGMA facility, simulating Fukushima Daiichi Unit 3 conditions. • Investigated how varying cooling temperatures affect steam condensation and non-condensable gas accumulation. • The highest helium concentrations were found in regions downstream of the injection point, where steam continues to condense. • The Shapiro ternary diagram showed a potential detonation risk in regions lower than injection point. • Findings provide critical insights into gas distribution patterns in reactor building during severe accident conditions.

Progress in Nuclear EnergyVol. 185
Japan Atomic Energy Agency (JP), Remote Sensing Technology Center of Japan (JP)
Openalex Percentile: Top 4%
Nuclear Physics and Applications
5.65
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.