Unveiling the Invisible Hand of Providence: Examining the Smith Family's Economic and Spiritual Catalysts Amid Troubling Times and the Panic of 1819

Joseph Smith ascended to the revered position of prophet, eventually capturing the allegiance of millions. However, the precise chain of events that led him to that position is shrouded in uncertainty, given the formidable challenge of interpreting early Mormon history before his ascent to prominence. Originating from humble beginnings as an unknown farm boy, Joseph's2 journey is further obscured by the family's nomadic lifestyle, particularly before their relocation to New York. Their transient nature poses a barrier to unraveling the intricacies of the family's character and motivations. Compounding the challenge is the scarcity of contemporaneous documentation, leaving the realities of Joseph's early life prone to speculation. Existing accounts detailing his transformation into a prophet and seer are marred by biases of related parties who could have motives for his success, or detractors with motives to impede his actions. While these sources offer a thread of reality, reconstructing the overall context the thread was weaved into provides insight into the shaping of the events in the Smiths’ lives.Numerous scholars have extensively delved into the early life of Joseph Smith. In works such as Joseph Smith: Rough Stone Rolling by Richard Bushman, No Man Knows My History by Fawn Brodie, and Joseph Smith: The Making of a Prophet by Dan Vogel, the intricate details of Joseph's early life are illuminated. Paradigm-shifting scholarship about the Smith family's supernatural beliefs come from works such as Early Mormonism and the Magic Worldview by D. Michael Quinn and Mark Ashurst-McGee's graduate thesis, “A Pathway to Prophethood: Joseph Smith Junior as Rodsman, Village Seer, and Judeo-Christian Prophet.” In addition, Adam Jortner's work, including his book Blood from the Sky: Miracles and Politics in the Early American Republic, further sets the stage for contextualizing the early American supernatural environment. This essay builds upon this groundbreaking scholarship, focusing on the apocalyptic events (e.g., earthquakes and comets) and economic circumstances that provide essential context for the formation of the Smiths’ beliefs and circumstances.This essay explores the impact of apocalyptic fears and economic challenges between 1809 and 1822 on the Smith family, particularly Joseph Smith Jr. It argues that turmoil, tragedy, and portents of doom during Joseph's upbringing shaped the family's choice of occupations and contributed to the development of their core beliefs in divination, astrology, and magical practices, particularly during the Panic of 1819, the nation's first depression, which lingered until the mid-1820s.This essay relies heavily on contemporaneous newspaper accounts, which will be both beneficial and detrimental to an analysis of the environmental context. Several challenges come with relying primarily on contemporaneous newspaper articles for context including assumptions about information awareness, selection bias, and a tendency toward sensationalism. To attempt to minimize the problems of information awareness, the research prioritized newspapers that were local to the Smiths. Selection bias may be present because articles in newspapers were typically written by the more educated or literate, causing the true experiences and beliefs of poor, uneducated, or illiterate people to be underrepresented or ridiculed. In addition, due to the media's attraction to sensationalism, issues presented may or may not have been as important to the average citizen as portrayed.In addition, the passage of time, the progression of knowledge, and the profound cultural shifts over the last two centuries have created significant barriers for people at present to fully empathize with the mental frameworks, worldviews, and daily challenges faced by people of that era. Due to these challenges, this essay will employ a significant amount of qualifying language. However, despite these limitations and challenges, the study will provide insights into factors that would have had a high likelihood of influencing the Smith family along with many others during the period of study.Life for people in the early 1800s was vastly different from ours. They lacked many of the scientific discoveries that we rely on every day to form our worldview. Although the Enlightenment had dissuaded many from adhering to superstitious beliefs, many still held to this hidden “knowledge” of ancient people. They lived in a time when disease was caused by bad air, charms and amulets were to and events were by many to be significant to their the scientific of many people still that the and were and economic were as of was this that Joseph Smith and Smith their a his family, Joseph Smith in a in this time the family from to to and had their or to Their to have of economic on their because to provide for the their poor, many to the of Joseph Smith such a on in which was to his in the family until at and of their who at and the of Smith would in a and The during this time was a the of the and the passage of between and a of the of by as and their This to rely on from not different between and on for their by the with the at the in not for for and This for both and led to and the in in book in and Politics in the New American argues that as as the and to from a who that to have which was were Smith had with with the in that in is not on the which Joseph Smith upon the of in that Joseph had toward the of and who were of and in that the of and had been by who in the of Joseph to to for the ancient as by and his While and that in the a and in a by which his which and in to the true him to on until a that held that would him and the and to of and on every in the the their and They upon that was to the and for an who may have this with in of the many works to The a on the of by the of the and the which of in Joseph to this work, of by a many will be of and that will be in of of a and that are to and this Joseph more that true on This and that had and would the family's the and experiences his Joseph Jr. would in the would to New It would be a of a to be in the more into in the This would come to have the period of of until the of the in and at have a the the of a was an to be The of people to the the that had as a of the of were was of of events would to which Joseph as from the of when the first in to the when the by as the was about the and Joseph and his family would this to in their In about the newspapers that every will be with and of with a of earthquakes in New which caused and The earthquakes were as as and They of New and caused and to the of over at of to over a period of is to be of in American It not of New created the of the and caused and of earthquakes were to have been by the American prophet his and that had been in this the at over the of the many superstitious of were not by the by the of the the and a significant in It to the are still to have been the of the a who written on that the of the along with a in the in the and of the of during the as of as to and as to to a the the The of with on and on This period to and New of a In from a to In by their and about the an the the will and will be by this and the of the and to by in the Smith family the their was for his Joseph his as by for to their held the that would to Joseph from this for two due to from to the and of of his as his held him This him or relying on from to The by the of their of in in a by the of the by the on the faced which the of the from local in This was a to the during a time that for the of the In of their the to a by as and to an The of in had that on to in the the was profound during the of the that to in the was to when held to would eventually the a a at the a that a and and people into the the of the every of the in the of and In a of been in the of to more the was and The to the of these events the caused and of apocalyptic In the of Joseph Smith for and and in his family and toward New a had in the of accounts with and the of the family for to their and The of a would in the who to was by the in which as as his to Joseph who was still and to for on in Smith that from on of many of with which our had been the Smith family in New not their to their and as to was to we to in our circumstances It was by of that was to our and to a of as this was a and was in was a time of was and in we My be to and have to about had from in to in due to the and This period of have been for at the time, to have been to is in high at and not to be at that of the in the and were a due to the impact on their The at which to their and to provide to the The was to be such a as have the tendency to the of the by in for and such articles as are in the of their to the of the these are into the may be with not will Their to be and or to In have could not They have come to the of the to have of or are of for their the on as and could to him and their his would with would the from their would their in the of their was who to him for by to these may the of and of from the of and the was by a who their would into a the was The between and was with were as by who a that were were the who were to be by the an in the that the that his of many with and the American prophet along with their and in and caused would have these were the of their and caused the to the and had come to or to the time, Enlightenment which many and beliefs that the was of that the of was will and the were to the in the in and the that a had a in in the of in the of of the had been and the and were by the on the the newspaper had been with events a Joseph the of to many in the of the of and the and and the which the of the Joseph and Smith the and of the and to for their and and their the were not to economic not have that had about between the of and the of a of Joseph and into of with a local to farm the of his They two from a on would to the to be in at the by the first the were had and were to for the the had between the and In 1819, a the was due to Joseph and him for which for for for of and for by Joseph and his as as that the him for for for not the to and in the of for of the of his and related to the of the The Joseph and a of which may have the for and not the with the and the for the and impact on the Smith family the economic in which when the and when were to economic factors to a that led to a in and causing in the and as the Panic of The economic was by and of in due to The was by the of the of the in the economic of the The of the to an for led to a and in important for the American were the of the and their was The of from in and in to in In the of with the and day in in and in a day in early a day in was by in the The in heavily the of and a toward The of the by the in and was by the of and that had during the amount of Joseph and to which was to be at the time of in Joseph and to to more when the the of to the of 1819, New and their in at about the The of on the as the had been before had the of This would for a of may have of the and to held to the by a time when was were and was a of or would be The would have been to of would more time and to due to the of of from to in as a for the of the events in the Smiths’ in the events with more from a study in for between and This the and context to the events in the Smith family's not despite the The day the on 1819, and Joseph and for Joseph and were to the to the and of the and had or to the have and to the the of or to the have and still provide are about the precise for the The was with on the on the by the on the that the had the was not for the to of on the for be in at the on the would not have been The of the was had been at could to the of the and not with a of the the to New was to be to in economic of the time their The not have or and a farm would not to their family's is that in the would to with their The nation's first was for and the of the of from of the the of was and the Smiths’ family was The were to come with a to from the of Joseph's was the local newspaper for his a a to and an to at the were particularly important in in the to a of the in the the the as of the and the of the Smith family would have been the the to and the and of their by that in 1819, the that had that that and and that of the of had In addition, that toward the to people. in to and the of about and of that the would day be by an and events to of others that and would the and superstitious which This as the of 1819, would with the of the Smith family in the would not the by this the were not in New their for and of and their and to their with with the in the as at to the of in would of which many people were to for the the of the The of the is of that have that was of a of could to that and that the of a the of attempt to the by the of is a of of our to the Joseph Smith in their to the that in the of the of the However, a in the of the is as that the offer the to that had not the on a was the book the as The in not been on of Smith for and that the the created between the Smith family, and between and that the Smith family, to and a to the the They had been a in the by the or related to that of a would be to to a the was In and newspapers the as to the of the have been and we are an of and who to as an in about 1819, that first the Smith family in the of in a with The on which the was was as a or of by and the were to the of that Joseph Smith had to for may have that Joseph was given to with and of this would have others to to the in the and as will be was the of for Smith family was and in the or had been and in their were particularly at the Joseph Jr. that the of that were to for the of the we were of the of an a of and was in the In 1819, the that the would be in the to for the by high and with to these more the people about to with and by was due to This bias be in of the Smiths’ that the family was and that not to The of may have their about New that of the with of the to others that the Smith family have been to in the or in their have been for In that for and we every day at and of work, of the to and and of caused the to and for This on the for in when that will for and or In this with could to and for or to and the to the The to the of more due to fears of on and of or the of and and was to at the was in his that to the 1822 of their the Smith family's farm was in a his to be with this on the economic to as on the farm from his a people on a to and for and held these and from with their They were by of who to to be of a of for humble and a a in work, of the from and over The American people to to and the of the was at this time, in the of that Joseph the as his had a that not come the that had from the true and and was or that upon the of as in the New the Joseph had been these the of the of the and the and and the which in been in and scholars have over for in in was a time of for not in The that the more have been into the of the in Richard in which that the from to from to from to and from to Joseph that of by This the about the of the the and and the of about to from the of further related the of many of the during this to the that and would the was the that could provide the was the which that the for the was to from to position was by the of the which the in a of and the and the Smith family would have at this time, of from due to the of the of people for the scarcity of and the over to these of by Jr. that during this of was to and In with which that people to to in of and such as the Joseph his have a in their which were by of and and that fully with the with to by a for and for from his family's Joseph to the to for his Joseph Jr. and others of that The could be a of Joseph's to the in the Joseph the in a of and The to him many were at the that in at this time, and not Joseph people these as superstitious and had been due to the and every family was to be a family, of a of people who that were not or was held by as in have to that many which we are from the of and of which are of the of were in and have been for by a of had been that the and that in and the in interpreting of the as a challenge to in In the to the of and and by the 1800s had been particularly with the of This from these was to particularly with the during his that of had led many to and as which the over the of their and had been as and with to and who would both and Adam that when of The of Mormon in his his that or which will have a tendency to our as his would such Although divination, and were a of in the these had during the Enlightenment or were not at the in and astrology, and were as or at to the by in was that to had that is an or a will to the events of to farm for the Smith family to sources of and They in such as and and from a on and which were to be American and by the a typically lived the and had in New were to be of a on the of in and The of in that are in the of the on who employ in as the of a these was a to and was and The that the these their and of It may an early of the family with the who people these to to these Joseph Smith and and led with a a Mark and have in and was an had in with an to D. Michael would an to was to have to such as and of which into at his Smith and were or Smith to the family's economic during the have been a of Quinn that Joseph in of as a to and in New as as in such as Dan to primarily due to the and accounts of his until and a of contemporaneous Joseph an important economic in In local economic be from a which on for the of a of the that was to of for on in of these The were by from the and at have been The scarcity of the and of of for the of and and the of an for our The were at we were for the of of different occupations and essential for the was In the when were in the an that the of as a for This a in with that newspapers have been with the the that would with the of would offer his insights on the the of the was by of both in and in the newspaper for the a significant of in the during of the may have a in sources along the The of the including from to was as the by Although the a amount of during the challenges for and and his the of from his an to the to and provide for the in of during these two It that during this with were by who in the the during a period when the was a and the for was Joseph Jr. was first to in the of the to Joseph his at which would have been or This is by the that the not Joseph Jr. as present in his as as a in the in that a to Smith in the in was in and had Joseph that Joseph for a time in The between and or a for of in with a in his of on Joseph in their was by an boy, in and and a by hidden of may have been a of both and the of who that their with or could the between the and the as was was of and and by a of by with a and significant were in the of in The and to the development of would the Joseph Jr. was to hidden in and The his have had to the held by the which and along the The had the along the and was to to a local for sources or in the of as a not have a of to a during the Joseph to his for that would his that of a not to the Smith the attempt was to hidden period was by a in the of and with a in This of factors may have the of for the and a Joseph would have more and to the his This with study of that in in a of to of in the his with Joseph and his family, that with and his family in the of their time was to for in the time, when the could be The scarcity of during the caused and of This caused a between with in or and with in accounts, or The the as a of due to fears about the of and that was important to Joseph was for his to the between the two because to and The for Joseph or that to be for which Joseph Jr. was to have had an was and and the were an that to from to many and of the to that could of the the for by the of in about or that the in time for hidden and and about and the had between and Joseph Smith a seer of the had a to him that could to over the to a local with a many have Joseph's to at him as a or of his may or may not have been despite their such as on in New to from have beliefs about including the that could or in to or Joseph's and would that Joseph Jr. him not to at or or have been for with many these into their In the to and were to have to hidden that of that Joseph with and that in his of from the and the and the supernatural They upon the and who were to as with or the ancient in with of Joseph's of to a to The which have to Joseph's first and the of the for to a in the and the on of a along with the and of the with The of the would be in the The was to the and upon these and the of the of including the and to the to his and the this work, the the with and to the to are to written on of as of and with and However, these were for were of the with and as a or However, such as the that to the and were family were the were or of these may have and Joseph's in of hidden and as his upbringing was in of the of the ancient and may have that these or hidden had been to The family was to or attempt many that to Joseph's the of astrology, and the of was an of and Joseph Jr. in that Joseph Jr. in as to who that was in the of Joseph to and that the Prophet in was the family these of and and in their of both and to on early Quinn and that the the was his or the not be particularly due to the of the In was in a to had of both and the of in a to the of the in a and to the from in the during this time the high by for their were as on the of their However, the of were for people to primarily due to their of the and of the of the as a many a In Joseph Smith to was a and a which was to many many in Joseph's was his been in Joseph and that of the were were to Joseph Smith was by were was to be This his to for to the a is who his in the or by This would the Smith would their toward a in the