Multi-Temporal Normalized Difference Vegetation Index Based on High Spatial Resolution Satellite Images Reveals Insight-Driven Edaphic Management Zones

Over the past quarter-century, the enhanced availability of satellite imagery, characterized by improved temporal, spectral, radiometric, and spatial resolutions, has enabled valuable insights into the spatial soil variability of annual croplands and orchards. This study investigates the impact of spatial resolution on classifying three-year, multi-temporal vegetation indices derived from satellites with coarse (30 m, Landsat 8), medium (10 m, Sentinel-2), and fine spatial resolutions (3.7 m, PlanetScope). The classification was performed using the fuzzy c-means algorithm, with the fuzziness performance index (FPI) and normalized classification entropy (NCE), which were used to determine the optimal number of management zones (MZs). Our results revealed that the Landsat 8-based NDVI images produced the highest number of clusters (nine for annual cropland and six for orchards), while the finer resolutions from PlanetScope reduced this to three clusters for both cultivation types, more accurately capturing the intra-parcel variability. Except for Landsat 8, the NDVI means of MZs generated based on Sentinel-2 and PlanetScope using the fuzzy c-means algorithm showed statistically significant differences from each other, as determined by a one-way and Welch’s ANOVA (p < 0.05). The use of PlanetScope imagery demonstrated its superiority in generating zones that reflect inherent variability, offering farmers actionable insights at a reconnaissance scale. Multi-temporal satellite imagery has proved effective in monitoring plant growth responses to edaphological soil properties. In our study, the PlanetScope satellites, which offer the highest spatial resolution, consistently produced effective zones for orchard areas. These zones have the potential to enhance farmers’ discovery of knowledge at a reconnaissance scale. With the increasing spatial resolution and enhanced spectral resolution of newer satellite sensors, using cluster analysis with insights from soil scientists promise to help farmers better understand and manage the fertility of their fields in a cost-effective manner.