NEW METHOD FOR PRACTICAL ASSESSMENT OF THE COMPLETENESS OF MACROBENTHOS SPECIES RICHNESS ESTIMATION AT DIFFERENT SAMPLING EFFORTS

Background. Species richness (SR) is recognized as the main parameter in calculating the structural biodiversity indices of any community. The relevance of SR evaluation is determined by the need to assess taxonomic knowledge of biota in the course of various ecological studies. The aim of this study is to perform a comparative prognostic assessment of the expected species richness (Sexp) of macrozoobenthos in 8 silty sand biotopes along the Crimean coast. Methods. This study involves the use of the data collected over the course of benthic surveys conducted in 1957-2009 (about 290 samples in total). The nonparametric extrapolation algorithms (estimators) from the groups Chao, jackknife and bootstrap have been applied for calculation of the parameters of region-specific model cumulative curves. Results. With application of various estimation algorithms, the pattern of randomized increment in the number of new species with the increase in the number of samples has been identified, as well as the realism of estimating the Sexp level relative to the number of observed species (Sobs) at different sampling efforts. The Chao-2 and JN-1 algorithms have been found to be the most feasible estimators for the expected species richness, as they provide the most realistic (20-38 %) exceedance of Sexp over Sobs at similar sampling effort. It is shown that the use of these estimators is effective when more than 20-25 samples are taken. A practical graphic calculation method for determining the conditionally complete species richness (or total observed species richness, Sobs-total) is proposed, which allows for optimization of the ratio between the number of samples and the completeness of the list of identified species. On the example of zoobenthos communities from the areas with different environmental conditions, it was calculated that, on average, at least 3-4 random samples should be taken to reveal 33 % of Sobs-total, and at least 6-7 samples should be analyzed to detect 50 % of it. Detection of 75 % and 90 % of the total number of species in a benthic community is possible with sampling more than 16-18 samples and 25 samples, respectively. Conclusion. The use of the proposed calculation method and the empirical relationships (number of species vs. number of samples) obtained on its basis is recommended for the enhancement of the completeness of benthos species richness assessment in insufficiently studied coastal aquatic areas of the Black Sea.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Водные биоресурсы и среда обитания
Published
2025-01-01
DOI
https://doi.org/10.47921/2619-1024_2025_8_1_55
Primary Topic
Insect Utilization and Effects
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

NEW METHOD FOR PRACTICAL ASSESSMENT OF THE COMPLETENESS OF MACROBENTHOS SPECIES RICHNESS ESTIMATION AT DIFFERENT SAMPLING EFFORTS

А. Н. Петров
Водные биоресурсы и среда обитания
Insect Utilization and Effects
article

NEW METHOD FOR PRACTICAL ASSESSMENT OF THE COMPLETENESS OF MACROBENTHOS SPECIES RICHNESS ESTIMATION AT DIFFERENT SAMPLING EFFORTS

А. Н. Петров
article en

Abstract

Background. Species richness (SR) is recognized as the main parameter in calculating the structural biodiversity indices of any community. The relevance of SR evaluation is determined by the need to assess taxonomic knowledge of biota in the course of various ecological studies. The aim of this study is to perform a comparative prognostic assessment of the expected species richness (Sexp) of macrozoobenthos in 8 silty sand biotopes along the Crimean coast. Methods. This study involves the use of the data collected over the course of benthic surveys conducted in 1957-2009 (about 290 samples in total). The nonparametric extrapolation algorithms (estimators) from the groups Chao, jackknife and bootstrap have been applied for calculation of the parameters of region-specific model cumulative curves. Results. With application of various estimation algorithms, the pattern of randomized increment in the number of new species with the increase in the number of samples has been identified, as well as the realism of estimating the Sexp level relative to the number of observed species (Sobs) at different sampling efforts. The Chao-2 and JN-1 algorithms have been found to be the most feasible estimators for the expected species richness, as they provide the most realistic (20-38 %) exceedance of Sexp over Sobs at similar sampling effort. It is shown that the use of these estimators is effective when more than 20-25 samples are taken. A practical graphic calculation method for determining the conditionally complete species richness (or total observed species richness, Sobs-total) is proposed, which allows for optimization of the ratio between the number of samples and the completeness of the list of identified species. On the example of zoobenthos communities from the areas with different environmental conditions, it was calculated that, on average, at least 3-4 random samples should be taken to reveal 33 % of Sobs-total, and at least 6-7 samples should be analyzed to detect 50 % of it. Detection of 75 % and 90 % of the total number of species in a benthic community is possible with sampling more than 16-18 samples and 25 samples, respectively. Conclusion. The use of the proposed calculation method and the empirical relationships (number of species vs. number of samples) obtained on its basis is recommended for the enhancement of the completeness of benthos species richness assessment in insufficiently studied coastal aquatic areas of the Black Sea.

Водные биоресурсы и среда обитанияVol. 8(1)
Openalex Percentile: Top 95%
Insect Utilization and Effects
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.