Comparison of naturally altered archaeological glasses from a marine environment with accelerated laboratory tests; implications for modelling long-term corrosion

Glass ingots of lead silicate composition from the shipwreck of the Albion were studied to ascertain the chemistry and mineralogy of alteration products after exposure to seawater for 220 years. Alteration observed on natural samples was compared to that of the same glasses exposed to short-term, high temperature, laboratory dissolution tests in synthetic seawater and significant differences were observed. Alteration layers on natural samples were more chemically complex having sequestered high concentrations of elements present only at trace quantities in seawater. Electron microprobe analysis and microfocus x-ray absorption spectroscopy shows that P, most likely released by biological activity in the vicinity of the wreck, accumulated in naturally altered samples to form Pb–Ca-phosphate phases whilst Pb-sulphate phases formed in laboratory tests. Meanwhile Fe, present at < 0.3 wt % in the glass and ppb concentrations in seawater, accumulated to form Fe-silicates whilst Mg-silicates predominated in laboratory tests. Biologically induced corrosion of naturally altered samples was also considered. Experiments conducted to test barnacle settlement rates suggest that biotoxic elements within the glass, primarily Pb but potentially also Cu, Co and Ni deterred barnacle settlement. Despite this toxicity, some colonisation of the glass surface by both barnacles and bryozoan did occur and, whilst barnacles appeared to protect against chemical attack, bryozoan colonies caused increased cracking, possibly due stress created at the glass surface. Results highlight the challenges in recreating open, natural systems in laboratory settings and demonstrate that elements present at low concentrations can have a significant impact over long timescales. • Glasses altered differently in the laboratory than in natural marine systems. • Minor elements sequestered over time controlled alteration mineralogy. • Results highlight challenge of recreating open, natural systems in the laboratory. • Natural analogues are useful for predicting the long term glass behaviour. • Results have implications for predicting evolution of vitrified nuclear waste.