Innovative Matrix-Based Assessment of Non-Conventional Water Processes: A Strategic Approach for Sustainable Water Management in Arid Environments

Water scarcity presents one of the greatest challenges of our time. Especially in naturally water-scarce regions, the need for additional water resources is rising, requiring innovative and site-adapted technologies. The decision for a specific technology is mostly associated with high investment costs and a long life cycle time, which requires a conscientious and transparent decision-making process. In this review, such a framework is developed for selected non-conventional water technologies and strategically evaluated with the goal to support a sustainable technology application based on specific boundary conditions. This is achieved by a matrix-based assessment and the development of key indicators respecting the availability, applicability, environmental impact, scalability, and economic viability of the selected technologies. Based on a wide literature review, the developed methodology involves a systematic comparison of technologies for desalination, water reuse, groundwater utilization, agricultural reuse, and unconventional approaches like cloud seeding, dew water, and fog water harvesting. The developed indicators cover most parameters of the respective categories based on the individual designs. Subsequently, the different technologies are analyzed by a matrix-based evaluation, highlighting various strengths and weaknesses and providing insights into technology application based on regional conditions. The discussion interprets the findings, deriving implications for dry environments, acknowledging limitations, and suggesting pathways for future research. The matrix-based evaluation is illustrated by an example from the Jordan Valley for a brackish water desalination plant. Through this analytical framework, this study contributes to the discourse on sustainable water solutions and a transparent decision-making process, as well as offers valuable insights for policymakers, researchers, and industries during a decision-making progress.