Contrasting alpha, beta, and gamma diversity in the littoral zones of mountain lakes: effects of habitat size and within-lake community structuring on bacterial biogeography

Research on microbial biogeography has revealed key patterns like the diversity-area relationship and distance-decay of similarity. However, how habitat size affects bacterial diversity in freshwater environments remains largely unclear. Here, we characterize bacterial communities in the littoral zones of 10 mountain lakes in the Sierra Nevada, CA, ranging in surface area from 0.92 to 71.72 ha. Despite significant habitat size effects on community composition, dominant bacterial phyla were shared across lakes. We found no evidence for diversity-area relationships, either in single samples (alpha diversity) or cumulative lake-level samples (within-lake gamma diversity), when accounting for environmental variation. Moreover, within-lake beta diversity showed little spatial structuring, with similar bacterial community composition across samples regardless of geographic distance. Gamma diversity did not reach saturation with our sample size, and lake size had no effect on the predicted sample size necessary to reach gamma diversity saturation. Our findings offer new insights into diversity-area dynamics and spatial structuring by investigating alpha, beta, and gamma diversity in freshwater environments. Notably, individual water samples captured much of the bacterial community, with strong correlations between alpha and gamma diversity. These results advance our understanding of microbial biogeography and inform sampling designs for characterizing bacterial diversity in freshwater ecosystems.