Innovative Aircraft Propulsive Configurations: Technology Evaluation and Operations in the SIENA Project

In this paper, developed in the context of the Clean Sky 2 project SIENA (Scalability Investigation of hybrid-Electric concepts for Next-generation Aircraft), an extensive analysis is carried out to identify and accelerate the development of innovative propulsion technologies and architectures that can be scaled across five aircraft categories, from small General Aviation airplanes to long-range airliners. The assessed propulsive architectures consider various components such as batteries and fuel cells to provide electricity as well as electric motors and jet engines to provide thrust, combined to find feasible aircraft architectures that satisfy certification constraints and deliver the required performance. The results provide a comprehensive analysis of the impact of key technology performance indicators on aircraft performance. They also highlight technology switching points as well as the potential for scaling up technologies from smaller to larger aircraft based on different hypotheses and assumptions concerning the upcoming technological advancements of components crucial for the decarbonization of aviation. Given the considered scenarios, the common denominator of the obtained results is hydrogen as the main energy source. The presented work shows that for the underlying models and technology assumptions, hydrogen can be efficiently used by fuel cells for propulsive and system power for smaller aircraft (General Aviation, commuter and regional), typically driven by propellers. For short- to long-range jet aircraft, direct combustion of hydrogen combined with a fuel cell to power the on-board subsystems appears favorable. The results are obtained for two different temporal scenarios, 2030 and 2050, and are assessed using Payload-Range Energy Efficiency as the key performance indicator. Naturally, introducing such innovative architectures will face a lack of applicable regulation, which could hamper a smooth entry into service. These regulatory gaps are assessed, detailing the level of maturity in current regulations for the different technologies and aircraft categories.