A Four-Year Retrospective of Mobile Access Bandwidth Evolution: The Inspiring, the Frustrating, and the Fluctuating

Recent advances in mobile technologies (like WiFi 6 and 5G) do not seem to deliver the promised access bandwidth. To effectively characterize mobile access bandwidth in the wild, we work with a major commercial mobile bandwidth testing app to conduct a long-term (2020-2023) and large-scale (involving 4.76M users) measurement study in China, based on coarse-grained general statistics and fine-grained sampling diagnostics. Our study presents distinct facts as to WiFi, 5G, and 4G: in the past few years, the average WiFi download bandwidth exhibits a considerable rise (by 119.7% ), the average 5G download bandwidth constantly decreases (by a total of 20.2% ) despite the enormous infrastructure investments, while the average 4G download bandwidth first declines (by 22.1% ) and then increases (by 22.5% ). The situations of upload bandwidths are generally similar to those of download bandwidths, except that 5G upload bandwidths manifest <i>N</i>-shaped <inline-formula><tex-math notation="LaTeX">$(\nearrow \searrow \nearrow )$</tex-math></inline-formula> fluctuations. Our cross-layer and cross-technology analysis reveals a variety of impact factors as well as their complicated interplay as the root causes, such as the bottlenecks in underlying infrastructure (e.g., communication devices and wired Internet access), the traffic offloading from one access technology to another, the influence of the COVID-19 pandemic, and the side effects of aggressively migrating radio resources from 4G to 5G. With the longitudinal, holistic picture of today's mobile access bandwidth, we finally provide multifold practical implications on closing the technology gaps.