The Late‐Quaternary Extinctions Gave Rise to Functionally Novel Herbivore Assemblages

Various authors have suggested that extinctions and extirpations of large mammalian herbivores during the last ca. 50,000 years have altered ecological processes. Yet, the degree to which herbivore extinctions have influenced ecosystems has been difficult to assess because past changes in herbivore impact are difficult to measure directly. Here, we indirectly estimated changes in (theorised) herbivore impact by comparing the functional composition of current large (≥ 10 kg) mammalian herbivore assemblages to those of a no-extinction scenario. As an assemblage's functional composition determines how it interacts with its environment, changes in functional compositions should correspond to changes in ecological impacts. We quantified functional composition using the body mass, diet and life habit of all wild herbivorous mammal species (<i>n</i> = 502) present during the last 130,000 years. Next, we assessed whether these changes in functional composition were large enough that the resulting assemblages could be considered functionally novel. Finally, we assessed where novel herbivore assemblages would most likely lead to changes in biome state. We found that 47% of assemblages are functionally novel, indicating fundamental changes in herbivore impacts occurred across much of the planet. On 20% of land, functionally novel herbivore assemblages have arisen in areas where alternative biome states are possible depending on the disturbance regime. Thus, in many regions, the late-Quaternary extinctions and extirpations altered herbivore assemblages so profoundly that there were likely major consequences for ecosystem functioning.