Subjective Fidelity Assessment of Audio- and Video-Driven Talking Head Generation Methods

Audio- and Video-Driven Talking Head Generation methods have attracted considerable research interest due to recent advances in Artificial Intelligence Generated Content (AIGC) technologies. In such approaches, a single image is artificially animated by leveraging audio and/or motion features extracted from video sources. Despite notable progress, current performance assessments rely primarily on traditional objective metrics, often neglecting subjective evaluation aspects. To address this issue, we propose in this paper a subjective fidelity assessment of recent Audio- and/or Video-Driven Talking Head Generation methods. This study aims to assess how accurately and convincingly the generated video reproduces the visual and behavioral characteristics of a real human face, as well as how closely the video aligns with expected natural human expressions, movements, and/or audio synchronization. In order to provide a detailed assessment of the fidelity in the context of talking heads, our study focuses on six key criteria: Overall Fidelity, Gaze Fidelity, Audio-Video Sync Fidelity, Head Pose Fidelity, Expression Fidelity, and Overall Visual Quality. Experiments results reveal a nuanced picture of the fidelity in this context, where the performance varies significantly depending on the video content itself as well as how the animation is generated, highlighting the needs for further research. This research represents an initial step towards the evaluation of Audio- and Video-Driven generative image animation methods for Talking heads while offering insights for improving the accuracy and realism of those techniques. The dataset and corresponding results are available at https://github.com/a-trioux/Subjective-Fidelity-Assessment-Talking-Head.