Assessing the Risk of Internal Loading of Phosphorus from Drinking Reservoir Sediments

The natural process of lake and reservoir eutrophication through nutrient accumulation within sediments has been accelerated through anthropogenic sources of nitrogen and, especially, phosphorus (P). Stored nutrients can result in significant internal loading (during periods of low sediment redox potential or elevated pH), which may drive poor water quality despite best practices in catchment management. Internal P loading can promote proliferation of cyanobacterial and algal taxa responsible for harmful algal blooms (HABs), as well as taste and odour (T&O) and cyanotoxin events. Here, we investigate the sediment and water column P content of eight reservoirs by analysing iron-bound (Fe-P), calcium-bound (Ca-P), and labile P fractions. We find that all but one reservoir demonstrated high iron (Fe) content (27–52 g Fe/kg sediment), suggesting a high Fe-P binding capacity and hence a potentially high susceptibility to redox-mediated internal loading. However, we found no correlation between Fe-P and Fe content in sediments, suggesting the Fe pool was not saturated with P and thus has capacity for further storage. All sites had low levels of labile P (up to 0.14 mg P-PO4/g dry sediment), with the highest pool of P being Ca-bound, which would be expected based on catchment geology and the presence of Ca-minerals which bind P. Currently, within industry, emphasis falls on controlling the external loading of nutrients from the surrounding catchment, often ignoring the critical role of internal loading. However, here, we demonstrate the need to continually monitor sediment P content and potential internal loading as part of the standard monitoring regime used by water companies to inform reservoir management strategies.