Deployment Architectures of MQTT Brokers in Event-Driven Industrial Internet of Things

The Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) involves various standards, protocols, and tools, requiring extensive expertise for system design. The traditional automation pyramid limits scalability due to tightly-coupled components. Integrating IIoT data in the cloud through event-driven communication, like MQTT brokers, provides loose coupling. This integration also aids in resource monitoring and planning, enhancing IIoT application performance. Despite many IIoT architecture studies, there is a lack of empirical comparisons of MQTT broker deployment strategies. This paper examines an edge-cloud aggregation scenario, where IIoT device requests are aggregated at the edge and fog services before being transmitted to the cloud. We study four MQTT deployment architectures and compare the results empirically. We use an Arduino Opta as an IIoT device. Also, we use software-based load generation to support replicability of our experiment and reproducibility of our results. Findings indicate that a central broker on a dedicated virtual machine gives 13.8% improvements of the mean response time compared to the shared deployment of MQTT broker and device gateways. Our results offer insights into effective deployment strategies.