Sensing presence: deathbots and bereavement hallucination

Abstract The prospects of AI-driven chatbots that can replicate the online presence of persons who have died (so-called ‘deathbots’) has given rise to concerns about the potential to replace the dead or disrupt the grieving process of their survivors. These concerns assume, however, that these ‘deathbots’ (hereafter Interactive Personality Constructs of the Dead, or IPCDs) could successfully replicate the experience of being in the (mediated) presence of a dead person. This paper considers recent discussions of the psychological phenomenon known as bereavement hallucination to determine what it is to experience the presence of a dead person, and whether chatbots could replicate this. Phenomenological analysis of bereavement hallucination suggests that the felt presence of the dead turns on an embodied sense of the opening-up of intersubjective possibilities by the characteristic way-of-being of the dead person. Once we understand the experience of the presence of the dead in this way, we can see that there are no apparent impediments to IPCDs producing such a sense of presence with the dead.