Interspecific Courtship Between Two Endemic Fireflies

Reproductive interactions between species could have negative effects on the fitness of the species involved, which can have important ecological and evolutionary consequences, such as population declines (including local extinction) or character divergence. Here, we report the courtship and attempted mating between two congeneric species of fireflies endemic to Mexico. The interactions involved males of the synchronous firefly Photinus palaciosi and females of the much larger, non-synchronous P. extensus. In the study site, the population density of P. palaciosi is much higher than that of P. extensus. Observations of marked P. extensus females throughout most of the mating season showed that 37.8% of their interactions with males were with P. palaciosi males. Although interspecific interactions were usually of shorter length, they frequently consumed a significant portion of the nightly mate-locating/courting period. These interspecific interactions are probably facilitated by the similarities in the mate location and courtship behavior of both species, which also share female brachyptery (elytra and wing reduction that makes females unable to fly). The simplest hypothesis to explain our behavioral observations is that P. palaciosi males mistakenly courted P. extensus females. The available evidence suggests that the operational sex ratio (OSR) of P. palaciosi is male-biased, as it seems to be the case in all synchronous fireflies studied to date. We hypothesize that the intense male competition for mates resulting from a male-biased OSR explains, at least in part, the “indiscriminate” sexual responses of P. palaciosi males. Another still not studied factor that could contribute to the frequent interspecific sexual interactions observed is the degree of similitude of the mating signals. The relatively high frequency of interspecific interactions and the significant amount of time invested in many of them (relative to the duration of the nightly mating period) indicate that the study of the potential fitness costs (and benefits?) of these interactions is a promising line of research.