Identification of region- and species-specific site conditions affecting drought vulnerability of young planted forests: An analysis of forest insurance data in Japan

• Forest insurance claim payments were used as an indicator of drought damage. • Factors affecting drought damage of young planted forests were analyzed using GIS. • Site conditions vulnerable to drought differed between regions and species. • Clayey soil was the drought risk factor in Kamikawa, but not in Yamaguchi region. • High risk at terraces with clay soil was found only for Japanese larch in Kamikawa. Due to the increasing frequency of extreme weather events, drought damage to trees threatens forestry production and forest ecosystems worldwide. Assessing the site conditions under which trees are vulnerable to drought damage provides key information for the establishment of countermeasures to prevent such damage. This study aimed to clarify the differences in drought vulnerability of young planted forests between regions and species by using forest insurance claims from all over Japan as a damage indicator. We targeted the two most damaged species in two of the most drought-affected regions from 2016 to 2021. Although landform and soil type were found to be influential factors in the Kamikawa Subprefecture of Hokkaido, these factors did not affect the drought damage in Yamaguchi Prefecture. In Kamikawa, the drought damage risk was high for Larix kaempferi on river terraces and for Abies sachalinensis on mountain areas with compacted brown forest soil. Clayey soil, which can prevent plants from absorbing water, has been known to distribute on the terraces and the mountains with compacted soil in Kamikawa. Therefore, our analysis identified clayey soil as a cause of drought vulnerability in Kamikawa. In addition, L. kaempferi was suggested to be especially vulnerable on flat terraces with less permeable clayey soil due to root damage associated with excessive soil moisture before drought. This study demonstrated that forest insurance can be used not only for damage compensation, but also as a source of information for identifying region- and species-specific risk factors for meteorological damage in forests.