Point prevalence surveys of acute infection presentation and antibiotic prescribing in selected primary healthcare facilities in North-West and Gauteng provinces of South Africa

ples.Mixed infection (minority strain 3% in Deeplex or any level in MAGMA) occurred in 3 samples.One sample was reported as 91% Mtb 2.2.1 + 8% Mtb 4.4.1.1 by MAGMA, and 87% M. bovis + 39% undefined Mtb lineage by Deeplex.One sample was reported as 99% NTM + 1% Mtb by MAGMA but 100% Mtb 4.3 by Deeplex.Another sample contained Mtb lineages 1, 2, 7, 4, 5, animal strains and M. canettii (4%) + undefined Mtb lineage (96%) in Deeplex and 100% Mtb 4.1.1.3 in MAGMA.The fourth sample contained two undefined lineages at 11% and 89% in Deeplex but 100% Mtb 2.2.1 in MAGMA.According to Deeplex, 33/53 samples shared an identical spoligotype (7 groups of size 2-19) and 20/53 had a unique spoligotype.Based on a 12 SNP cut-off, 4 samples were part of a WGS cluster and 55/59 were unclustered.Of the spoligotype groups, only one group of the 7 groups at least 2 identical spoligotypes had a SNP distance < 12. Strain typing for strains identified by MAGMA as lineage 4 were varied in the Deeplex analysis, apart from strains identified by both as sublineage 4.3Discussion: A significant proportion of the samples analysed by Deeplex were reported as "Other than lineage 4.9".This definition is not informative for strain typing.The resolution of Deeplex is less granular than WGS; it failed to assign sublineage for approximately two-thirds of the samples for which it could assign lineage.Deeplex particularly struggles with strain typing for lineage 4 strains unless they are lineage 4.3 strains. Conclusion:Our findings highlight poor phylogenetic resolution of tNGS, limiting its ability to inform public health interventions.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
International Journal of Infectious Diseases
Published
2025-02-28
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijid.2024.107689
Citations
6
Primary Topic
Primary Care and Health Outcomes
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
16.89
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Point prevalence surveys of acute infection presentation and antibiotic prescribing in selected primary healthcare facilities in North-West and Gauteng provinces of South Africa

Mahlatse Kganyago, Matthew Cook, Patric-Alain Meyer, Paul V. Campbell et al.
6 citations
International Journal of Infectious Diseases
Primary Care and Health Outcomes
16.89
article

Point prevalence surveys of acute infection presentation and antibiotic prescribing in selected primary healthcare facilities in North-West and Gauteng provinces of South Africa

Mahlatse Kganyago, Matthew Cook, Patric-Alain Meyer, Paul V. Campbell, Miss Audrey Chigome, Dr Jan Goelen, Miss Sasha Vambe, Professor Brian Godman, Dr Phumzile Skosana, Professor Natalie Schellack, Dr William Cuningham
article en
6 citations

Abstract

ples.Mixed infection (minority strain 3% in Deeplex or any level in MAGMA) occurred in 3 samples.One sample was reported as 91% Mtb 2.2.1 + 8% Mtb 4.4.1.1 by MAGMA, and 87% M. bovis + 39% undefined Mtb lineage by Deeplex.One sample was reported as 99% NTM + 1% Mtb by MAGMA but 100% Mtb 4.3 by Deeplex.Another sample contained Mtb lineages 1, 2, 7, 4, 5, animal strains and M. canettii (4%) + undefined Mtb lineage (96%) in Deeplex and 100% Mtb 4.1.1.3 in MAGMA.The fourth sample contained two undefined lineages at 11% and 89% in Deeplex but 100% Mtb 2.2.1 in MAGMA.According to Deeplex, 33/53 samples shared an identical spoligotype (7 groups of size 2-19) and 20/53 had a unique spoligotype.Based on a 12 SNP cut-off, 4 samples were part of a WGS cluster and 55/59 were unclustered.Of the spoligotype groups, only one group of the 7 groups at least 2 identical spoligotypes had a SNP distance < 12. Strain typing for strains identified by MAGMA as lineage 4 were varied in the Deeplex analysis, apart from strains identified by both as sublineage 4.3Discussion: A significant proportion of the samples analysed by Deeplex were reported as "Other than lineage 4.9".This definition is not informative for strain typing.The resolution of Deeplex is less granular than WGS; it failed to assign sublineage for approximately two-thirds of the samples for which it could assign lineage.Deeplex particularly struggles with strain typing for lineage 4 strains unless they are lineage 4.3 strains. Conclusion:Our findings highlight poor phylogenetic resolution of tNGS, limiting its ability to inform public health interventions.

International Journal of Infectious DiseasesVol. 152
Openalex Percentile: Top 1%
Primary Care and Health Outcomes
16.89
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.