Revisiting the assignment of atomic charges in metal oxides based on core-level x-ray photoelectron spectra: The case of Ti in SrTiO3(001)

We demonstrate that assigning formal charges to transition metal (TM) cations based on core-level (CL) x-ray photoemission binding energies in oxides leads to physically inconsistent pictures of electronic structure. O 2p–TM 3d hybridization is well known to result in significant covalency in TM–O bonds, thereby reducing TM cation charges from their fully ionic values. However, the ionic bonding model remains the working paradigm for assigning TM CL features, and the resulting cation charges are often taken to be representative of the material under study. Here, we show that a more physically meaningful way to assign charges is to extract information about charge distributions utilizing Dirac–Hartree–Fock theory to calculate CL spectra from first principles and then use the resulting wave functions to determine charges based on orbital occupancies. TM cation charges can also be determined using density functional theory and Bader population analysis. We illustrate these two methods using the Ti 2p spectrum for SrTiO3(001) and show that the agreement between them is excellent. Significantly, the resulting Ti charge is considerably lower than the formal charge. The high degree of similarity between the Ti 2p spectrum for SrTiO3 and those for the rutile and anatase polymorphs of TiO2 suggests that the charge densities surrounding Ti in the latter materials are similar to that in SrTiO3. Taking a broader perspective, oxides containing other first-row transition metals also exhibit covalent character, leading to TM cation charges lower than the analogous fully ionic values in these materials as well.