Rapid Profiling of Volatile Organic Compounds Associated with Plant-Based Milks Versus Bovine Milk Using an Integrated PTR-ToF-MS and GC-MS Approach

The growing demand for plant-based beverages has underscored the importance of investigating their volatile profiles, which play a crucial role in sensory perception and consumer acceptance. This is especially true for plant-based milks (PBMs) that have a clear reference model in bovine milk. This study characterises the volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in soy, almond and oat beverages compared to bovine milk using proton transfer reaction-time of flight-mass spectrometry (PTR-ToF-MS) as a rapid and noninvasive screening tool, complemented by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) for compound identification. A total of 188 mass peaks were detected by PTR-ToF-MS, all showing significant differences from the blank, while GC-MS allowed the identification of 50 compounds, supporting the tentative identifications performed with PTR-MS analysis. In order to facilitate a comparison of different milks, after statistical analysis, these 188 mass peaks were further categorised into two groups: one consisting of VOCs with minimal variability across all samples and another comprising VOCs with significantly different abundances, distinctly characterising each beverage. Principal component analysis revealed a clear separation between bovine milk and PBMs, with almond beverages exhibiting the richest volatilome, while oat beverages displayed a more homogeneous volatile profile. PTR-ToF-MS demonstrated its ability to analyse volatile profiles rapidly, with excellent complementarity to GC-MS in terms of analytical versatility. The results provided a valuable basis for testing new experimental designs aimed to characterise and enhance flavour profiles in plant-based beverages, also after processing, in case of new product development that considers using these milks as raw materials.