A105: Correlation Analysis Between Cognitive Style and Judgment Accuracyof Tennis Umpires in Zhejiang Province

<bold>Background/Purpose:</bold> The influence of cognitive style on decision-making in sports has always been a hot research direction in sports psychology. As the law enforcers in the stadium, the individual cognitive style of the umpire in the penalty will also affect the results of a game to an extent. This paper studied the accuracy of on-the-spot decision-making judgment of tennis umpires classified by field dependent-field independent cognitive style and provided a new idea and scientific method for the selection and cultivation of tennis umpires. <bold>Methods/Design:</bold> In this experiment, literature method, experimental method, mathematical statistics, logical analysis method and other related research methods were used. In the experimental method, a total of 68 tennis umpires of three, two, one and national level in Zhejiang province were selected as research objects. Their field-dependent-field-independent cognitive styles were distinguished by Rod-Frame tests, using video experiments to obtain the experimental results. <bold>Results:</bold> As the level of umpires increases, the proportion of umpires with field-independent cognitive style increases, and the proportion of umpires with field-dependent cognitive style decreases. There is no significant difference in video experiment between umpires of the same level and different ages. Short-term training (one month) can improve the accuracy of umpires' judgment, but the improvement of first-level and national-level umpires is not obvious, and the improvement of second-level and third-level umpires is significant. There was no significant correlation between field cognitive style and video experiment results in the second and third-level umpires. In the first-level and national umpires, there is a significant correlation between field cognitive style and video experiment results. The correct rate of video experiment of field-independent umpires is significantly higher than that of field-dependent umpires. <bold>Conclusion:</bold> Level and cognitive style are important factors affecting the accuracy of umpire judgment. In low-level umpires, training is an important means to enhance the level of decision-making. Among high-level umpires, field-independent umpires have more potential and development space than field-dependent umpires.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
International Journal of Physical Activity and Health
Published
2024-12-01
DOI
https://doi.org/10.18122/ijpah.3.3.105.boisestate
Primary Topic
Sports Analytics and Performance
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

A105: Correlation Analysis Between Cognitive Style and Judgment Accuracyof Tennis Umpires in Zhejiang Province

Wensheng He, Kunyan Cai
International Journal of Physical Activity and Health
Sports Analytics and Performance
article

A105: Correlation Analysis Between Cognitive Style and Judgment Accuracyof Tennis Umpires in Zhejiang Province

Wensheng He, Kunyan Cai
article en

Abstract

<bold>Background/Purpose:</bold> The influence of cognitive style on decision-making in sports has always been a hot research direction in sports psychology. As the law enforcers in the stadium, the individual cognitive style of the umpire in the penalty will also affect the results of a game to an extent. This paper studied the accuracy of on-the-spot decision-making judgment of tennis umpires classified by field dependent-field independent cognitive style and provided a new idea and scientific method for the selection and cultivation of tennis umpires. <bold>Methods/Design:</bold> In this experiment, literature method, experimental method, mathematical statistics, logical analysis method and other related research methods were used. In the experimental method, a total of 68 tennis umpires of three, two, one and national level in Zhejiang province were selected as research objects. Their field-dependent-field-independent cognitive styles were distinguished by Rod-Frame tests, using video experiments to obtain the experimental results. <bold>Results:</bold> As the level of umpires increases, the proportion of umpires with field-independent cognitive style increases, and the proportion of umpires with field-dependent cognitive style decreases. There is no significant difference in video experiment between umpires of the same level and different ages. Short-term training (one month) can improve the accuracy of umpires' judgment, but the improvement of first-level and national-level umpires is not obvious, and the improvement of second-level and third-level umpires is significant. There was no significant correlation between field cognitive style and video experiment results in the second and third-level umpires. In the first-level and national umpires, there is a significant correlation between field cognitive style and video experiment results. The correct rate of video experiment of field-independent umpires is significantly higher than that of field-dependent umpires. <bold>Conclusion:</bold> Level and cognitive style are important factors affecting the accuracy of umpire judgment. In low-level umpires, training is an important means to enhance the level of decision-making. Among high-level umpires, field-independent umpires have more potential and development space than field-dependent umpires.

International Journal of Physical Activity and HealthVol. 3(3)
Zhejiang Normal University (CN)
Openalex Percentile: Top 69%
Sports Analytics and Performance
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.