Innovative Nafion- and Lignin-Based Cation Exchange Materials Against Standard Resins for the Removal of Heavy Metals During Water Treatment

The contamination of water by heavy metals poses an escalating risk to human health and the environment, underscoring the critical need for efficient removal methods to secure safe water resources. This study evaluated the performance of four cationic exchange materials (labeled “PS—DVB”, “PA—DVB”, “TFSA”, and “OGL”) in removing or harvesting metals such as copper, silver, lead, cobalt, and nickel from aqueous solutions, several of which are precious and/or classified as Critical Raw Materials (CRMs) due to their economic importance and supply risk. The objective was to screen and benchmark the four ion exchange materials for water treatment applications by investigating their metal sequestration capacities. Experiments were conducted using synthetic solutions with controlled metal concentrations, analyzed through ICP-OES, and supported by kinetic modeling. The adsorption capacities (qe) obtained experimentally were compared with those predicted by pseudo-first-order and pseudo-second-order models. This methodology enables high precision and reproducibility, validating its applicability for assessing ion exchange performance. The results indicated that PS—DVB and PA—DVB resins proved to be of “wide range”, exhibiting high efficacy for most of the metals tested, including CRM-designated ones, and suggesting their suitability for water purification. Additionally, the second-life Nafion-based “TFSA” material demonstrated commendable performance, highlighting its potential as a viable and technologically advanced alternative in water treatment. Lastly, the lignin-based material, “OGL”, representing the most innovative and sustainability apt option, offered relevant performance only in selected cases. The significant differences in performance among the resins underscore the impact of structural and compositional factors on adsorption efficiency. This study offers valuable insights for investigating and selecting new sustainable materials for treating contaminated water, opening new pathways for targeted and optimized solutions in environmental remediation.