When Law Came to Adam: The Origin Story of Sin and Death in Romans 5

In Romans 5, Paul says that prior to law “sin is not counted” (v. 13), and that upon law’s arrival, “the trespass increased” (v. 20). For most interpreters, the law that counted sin and increased the trespass is the law that God revealed to Israel at Sinai. Origen of Alexandria offered significant exegetical objections to this reading and proposed that natural law is in view. I modify Origen’s proposal to align Paul with the early Jewish tradition of Adam’s law, and I argue that “law” in vv. 13a and 20 refers to law’s arrival to Adam. Romans 5:12–21 is Paul’s re-telling of Scripture and chronicles Sin and Death achieving their global reigns. Understood this way, vv. 12–14 and 20–21 tell us what transpired when God’s law came to Adam: Sin and Death united, and they launched and secured their cosmic tyranny. This is Sin and Death’s origin story.