Highlighting the Importance of Correct Sex Identification in Chondrichthyan Genomic Studies, Using the White Shark as an Example

The increased availability of reference genome assemblies of sharks and rays has contributed greatly to our understanding of their biology, including their sex-determination mechanisms. However, several publicly available genome assemblies of sharks and rays appear to be missing information about the sex of the source individuals. This can confound the investigation into genetic sex-determining elements and hinder the discovery of sex-specific patterns. Herein, we highlight the importance of clear and accurate sex identification in sharks and rays for future genome assemblies, using an example of a white shark (Carcharodon carcharias) genome, in which the phenotypically assigned sex conflicts with the genetic information. This genome assembly was reported to be sourced from a juvenile female (BioSample: SAMN01915239). We analyzed the assembly by mapping its available genome sequences to the current white shark reference genome assembly and compared the read coverage to sequences collected from other samples. Evidence suggests that this specimen is genetically male, which contradicts its assignment based on phenotype. Therefore, we urge researchers to provide as much accurate information (e.g., sex, sampling localities, and life history) as possible when publishing genome assemblies for sharks and rays (or for any other organism).