Bending properties of human cartilaginous ribs and costal cartilage material vary with age, sex, and calcification

Costal cartilage plays an important functional role in the rib cage, but its mechanical properties have not been well characterized. The objective of this study is to characterize the properties of human costal cartilage and examine the effects of age, sex, rib level, and degree of calcification. We obtained cadaveric costal cartilage samples of ribs 3-6 with intact perichondrium from 24 donors (12 females and 12 males) evenly distributed by age (range 47-94 yr). Peripheral QCT scans were used to quantify geometric properties (area moments) and tissue calcification (as volume, length, and classified as central, peripheral, and mixed). Four-point bending tests were performed on each sample, and bending stiffness and modulus outcomes were evaluated by fitting data from mechanical testing with non-linear pseudo-elastic models (composed of linear and cubic components, separated into loading and unloading regimes). Effects of sex, age, rib level, and cartilage calcification on bending stiffness and modulus outcomes were assessed with mixed-effects regression models. Cartilage size (area moment) was larger in males than females and positively associated with age, while there was more calcification volume in cartilage of females than males. During loading, stiffness (linear and cubic) was larger in males, while modulus (linear and cubic) was larger in females. Linear stiffness and modulus were both negatively associated with age, positively associated with calcification, and varied between rib levels. Cubic (nonlinear) components of stiffness and modulus were positively associated with calcification and varied by rib, while modulus (but not stiffness) was negatively associated with age. During unloading, the linear stiffness and modulus values were much lower, though some similar associations were found. Overall, this study adds to our understanding of the behavior of costal cartilage as a nonlinear visco-elastic material, and the effects of sex, aging, and calcification on mechanical behavior.