PD-1 antibody interactions with Fc gamma receptors enable PD-1 agonism to inhibit T cell activation – therapeutic implications for autoimmunity

PD-1 has emerged as a central inhibitory checkpoint receptor in maintaining immune homeostasis and as a target in cancer immunotherapies. However, targeting PD-1 for the treatment of autoimmune diseases has been more challenging. We recently showed in a phase 2a trial that PD-1 could be stimulated with the PD-1 agonist antibody peresolimab to treat rheumatoid arthritis. Here, we demonstrate that PD-1 antibodies can elicit agonism and inhibit T cell activation by co-localization of PD-1 with the T cell receptor via Fcγ receptor (FcγR) engagement. Three PD-1 agonist antibodies with different antigen binding domains, including the clinically validated PD-1 blocking antibody pembrolizumab, suppressed T cell activation to a similar degree; this finding suggests that a specific PD-1-binding epitope is not required for PD-1 agonism. We next explored whether antibody-mediated clustering was an important driver of inhibition of T cell activation; however, we found that a monovalent PD-1 antibody was not inferior to a conventional bivalent antibody in its ability to suppress T cell activation. Importantly, we found that affinity to PD-1 correlated positively with inhibition of T cell activation, with higher affinity antibodies exhibiting higher levels of inhibition. Using a series of human Fc mutants with altered affinities to various FcγRs, we dissected the contributions of FcγRs and found that multiple FcγRs rather than a single receptor contribute to agonist activity. Our work reveals an important role for FcγR binding in the activity of PD-1 antibodies, which has implications for optimizing both PD-1 agonist and antagonist antibodies.