Advancing Forest Plot Surveys: A Comparative Study of Visual vs. LiDAR SLAM Technologies

Forest plot surveys are vital for monitoring forest resource growth, contributing to their sustainable development. The accuracy and efficiency of these surveys are paramount, making technological advancements such as Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM) crucial. This study investigates the application of SLAM technology, utilizing LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging) and monocular cameras, to enhance forestry plot surveys. Conducted in three 32 × 32 m plots within the Tibet Autonomous Region of China, the research compares the efficacy of LiDAR-based and visual SLAM algorithms in estimating tree parameters such as diameter at breast height (DBH), tree height, and position, alongside their adaptability to forest environments. The findings revealed that both types of algorithms achieved high precision in DBH estimation, with LiDAR SLAM presenting a root mean square error (RMSE) range of 1.4 to 1.96 cm and visual SLAM showing a slightly higher precision, with an RMSE of 0.72 to 0.85 cm. In terms of tree position accuracy, the three methods can achieve tree location measurements. LiDAR SLAM accurately represents the relative positions of trees, while the traditional and visual SLAM systems exhibit slight positional offsets for individual trees. However, discrepancies arose in tree height estimation accuracy, where visual SLAM exhibited a bias range from −0.55 to 0.19 m and an RMSE of 1.36 to 2.34 m, while LiDAR SLAM had a broader bias range and higher RMSE, especially for trees over 25 m, attributed to scanning angle limitations and branch occlusion. Moreover, the study highlights the comprehensive point cloud data generated by LiDAR SLAM, useful for calculating extensive tree parameters such as volume and carbon storage and Tree Information Modeling (TIM) through digital twin technology. In contrast, the sparser data from visual SLAM limits its use to basic parameter estimation. These insights underscore the effectiveness and precision of SLAM-based approaches in forestry plot surveys while also indicating distinct advantages and suitability of each method to different forest environments. The findings advocate for tailored survey strategies, aligning with specific forest conditions and requirements, enhancing the application of SLAM technology in forestry management and conservation efforts.