Understanding the Directed Evolution of a Natural-like Efficient Artificial Metalloenzyme

The artificial metalloenzyme containing iridium in place of iron along with four directed evolution mutations C317G, T213G, L69V, and V254L in a natural cytochrome P450 presents an important milestone in merging the extraordinary efficiency of biocatalysts with the versatility of small molecule chemical catalysts in catalyzing a new-to-nature carbene insertion reaction. This is a show-stopper enzyme, as it exhibits a catalytic efficiency similar to that of natural enzymes. Despite this remarkable discovery, there is no mechanistic and structural understanding as to why it displays extraordinary efficiency after the incorporation of the four active site mutations by directed evolution methods, which so far has been intractable to any experimental methods. In this study, we have deciphered how directed evolution mutations gradually alter the protein conformational ensemble to populate a catalytically active conformation to boost a multistep catalysis in a natural-like artificial metalloenzyme using large-scale molecular dynamics simulations, rigorous quantum chemical (QM), and multiscale quantum chemical/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) calculations. It reveals how evolution precisely positions the cofactor-substrate in an unusual but effective orientation within a reshaped active site in the catalytically active conformation stabilized by C-H···π interactions from more ordered mutated L69V and V254L residues to achieve preferential transition state stabilization compared to the ground state. This work essentially tracks down in atomistic detail the shift in the conformational ensemble of the highly active conformation from the less efficient single mutant to the most efficient quadruple mutant and offers valuable insights for designing better enzymes. The active conformation correctly reproduces the experimental barrier height and also accounts for the catalytic effect, which is in good agreement with experimental observations. Moreover, this conformation features an unusual bonding interaction in a metal-carbene species that preferentially stabilizes the rate-determining formation of an iridium porphyrin carbene intermediate to render the observed high catalytic rate acceleration. Our study provides crucial insights into the underlying rationale for directed evolution, reports the major catalytic role of nonelectrostatic interactions in enzyme catalysis different from the electrostatic model, and suggests a crucial principle toward designing enzymes with natural efficiency.