IEEE 802.15.6 and LoRaWAN for WBAN in Healthcare: A Comparative Study on Communication Efficiency and Energy Optimization

Wireless body area networks (WBANs), which continually gather and transmit patient health data in real time, are essential for improving healthcare administration. Patient outcomes can be improved by sending these data to medical professionals for prompt review and treatment. For the effective deployment of WBANs, communication solutions are necessary to maximize critical performance parameters, such as low power consumption, minimal delay, and acceptable data rates, while guaranteeing dependable transmission. Two prominent technologies in this field are LoRaWAN, which is renowned for its long-range capabilities and energy efficiency, and IEEE 802.15.6, which was created especially for short-range medical applications with high data throughput. This study provides a comparative evaluation of these two technologies to determine their suitability for diverse WBAN healthcare scenarios. By using the NS3, a simulation was performed to calculate six key performance metrics: throughput, arrival rate, delay, energy consumption, packet delivery ratio (PDR), and network lifetime. The study analyzed each technology’s performance under varying node counts. At a density of 50 nodes, IEEE 802.15.6 demonstrated superior throughput, with 45 kbps, compared to LoRaWAN, and a higher PDR of 30%. Additionally, IEEE 802.15.6 showed a higher arrival rate, of 0.33%, than LoRaWAN. On the other hand, LoRaWAN showed notable strengths in energy consumption, with only 42 J, compared to IEEE 802.15.6, and significantly lower delay, with a delay of 7 s. Additionally, LoRaWAN offered an extended network lifetime, of 18 h, compared to IEEE 802.15.6.