Mixtures of toxic organic micropollutants compromise the safety of water resources in urban agglomerations in low- and medium-income countries: The example of Lahore, Pakistan

Contamination of water resources with mixtures of organic micropollutants (OMP) including pesticides, pharmaceuticals, and industrial chemicals is a serious threat to aquatic organisms and human health. Long-term exposure to such pollutants may cause detrimental effects even at very low concentrations. Water resources in urban agglomerations in low- and medium-income countries may be under particular pressure due to high population densities, significant industrial activities, and limited water treatment and management resources. In these areas, many inhabitants directly rely on healthy urban water resources. Using the agglomeration of Lahore, Pakistan, as a case, we studied the occurrence, spatial distribution, and toxic risks of OMP mixtures in different urban water resources using target screening with liquid chromatography high-resolution mass spectrometry. In total, 266 of 576 target analytes were detected in at least one of the 200 samples taken from groundwater, canals, River Ravi and drains within the urban agglomeration. Notably, very high concentrations ranging from 10 to over 100 μg L^-1 were found for highly toxic pesticides including several fungicides such as picoxystrobin, the transformation product phthalamic acid, and imazalil, the insecticide etofenprox but also industrial chemicals stemming for example from traffic such as 2-naphthalene sulfonic acid. Our study revealed high toxic risks particularly for invertebrates, fish and algae, with etofenprox as a dominant risk driver. This compound is extensively used in Lahore to control insect vectors of malaria and dengue fever in the urban agglomeration. Mixture risks were assessed using a toxic unit (TU) approach based on organism group specific effect concentrations, complemented with a risk quotient (RQ) approach using the lowest predicted no effect concentrations (PNECs). Acute and chronic risk thresholds were frequently exceeded, often by many orders of magnitude. These very high mixture risks strongly exceed those with previous studies in Europe, Africa and South America.