Comparison and Analysis of CALIPSO Aerosol Optical Depth and AERONET Aerosol Optical Depth Products in Asia from 2006 to 2023

Aerosol optical depth (AOD) serves as a significant parameter in aerosol research. With the increasing utilization of satellite data in AOD research, it is crucial to evaluate the satellite AOD data. Using Aerosol Robotic Network (AERONET) in situ measurements, this study investigates the accuracy and applicability of Cloud-Aerosol Lidar and Infrared Pathfinder Satellite Observations (CALIPSO) AOD data in Asia from June 2006 to June 2023. By matching the CALIPSO AOD data in a 1° × 1° area around the selected AERONET sites, various statistical metrics were used to create a comprehensive evaluation system. The results show that: (1) There is a high correlation between the AODs of CALIPSO and AERONET (R = 0.636), and the AOD values of CALIPSO are only 1.7% higher than those of AERONET on average. The MAE (0.215) and RMSE (0.358) suggest that the error level of CALIPSO AOD is relatively low; (2) In most of the 25 sites throughout Asia CALIPSO AOD have high matching accuracies with the AERONET AOD, and only in three sites has a validation accuracy of ‘Poor’; (3) The accuracy varies across the four seasons, ranked as follows: winter demonstrates the highest accuracy, followed by autumn, spring, and summer; (4) The accuracy varies with surface elevation, with better matching in lowest altitude (<50 m) and high altitude (>500 m) areas, but slightly worse matching in medium altitude (200–500 m) areas and low altitude (50–200 m). The uncertainty in the CALIPSO AOD retrievals varies in seasons, altitudes, and aerosol characteristics.