Comparison of Full-Arch Intraoral Scans Immediately After Implant Insertion Versus Healed Tissue: A Multicentric Clinical Study

Objectives: The purpose of this clinical study is to compare implant full-arch intraoral scans taken immediately after implant placement with those obtained after tissue healing in patients rehabilitated with implant-supported fixed prostheses. Methods: Between September 2023 and March 2024, a total of 19 patients with compromised residual dentition (6 women; 13 men) were rehabilitated using 4-to-6 immediately loaded post-extraction implants. These implants supported fixed full-arch screw-retained prostheses either in the lower jaw (9 patients) or upper jaw (10 patients). Intraoral scans were taken immediately after implant placement (termed “immediate scan”). After a healing period of four months, the provisional prosthesis was removed, and a second intraoral scan was performed using the same scan bodies and scan pattern as the initial scan (termed “delayed scan”). The two scans were overlaid, and the discrepancies between them were measured. Results: The average discrepancy between the immediate and delayed scans was 0.1905 mm. Our statistical analysis revealed larger discrepancies for implants placed in the posterior areas, with the implant in site 1.6 (Implant 1) showing a discrepancy of 0.2326 mm, and the implant in site 2.6 (Implant 4) showing a discrepancy of 0.2124 mm (p = 0.05). No statistically significant difference was observed when comparing patients treated in the upper and lower jaws. Conclusions: Within the limitations of the study and based on this result, clinicians should be aware that an immediate post-surgical intraoral digital scan for implant-supported full-arch rehabilitations may result in a higher risk of imprecision. Furthermore, according to the results of the study, the accuracy of the digital impression on implant full-arch rehabilitations seems to be influenced by the clinician’s skills. Further studies with larger sample sizes are required to confirm our results.