Effects of Straw and Green Manure Addition on Crop Yield, Soil Properties and CH4 Emissions: A Meta-Analysis

The incorporation of organic amendments is widely acknowledged for its capacity to enhance soil fertility and boost crop productivity. However, whether the addition of organic amendments can improve soil quality and crop production, simultaneously causing methane emissions in paddy fields, deserves further investigation. In this meta-analysis, the effects of different organic amendments on soil nutrient levels, rice yield and CH4 emissions were evaluated in paddy fields based on 328 observations from 77 field trial studies. Our results revealed that the addition of organic amendments significantly increased soil organic carbon (9.47%), microbial biomass carbon (21.13%), microbial biomass nitrogen (28.91%), urease (25.07%) and β-glucosidase (24.41%). Moreover, straw addition significantly increased the CH4 emissions by 152.68% and rice yield by 7.16%; green manure addition significantly increased CH4 emissions by 71.62% and rice yield by 10.09%, respectively. Although both increased the CH4 emissions, green manure had the ability to improve the availability of N, which could improve rice uptake. The regression results showed that the variation in crop yield, soil nutrients and CH4 emissions are influenced through the types and quality of organic amendments. Overall, this study suggests that organic amendments are beneficial in maintaining soil quality and improving rice yield, whereas it also increased the CH4 emissions. These meta-analysis results may provide some references for optimizing organic amendments incorporated into the soil to sustain soil fertility and crop production while mitigating soil constraints and methane emissions.