Chris Callow, Landscape, Tradition and Power in Medieval Iceland. Dalir and Eyjafjörður Region c. 870–1265, Leiden: Brill 2020

This book compares systems of geopolitical power including the formation of alliances through marriages in two regions of Iceland, Dalir and Eyjafjrur, as found in the Sagas of Icelanders (slendingasgur), The Book of Settlements (Landnmabk), Contemporary sagas (Sturlunga saga) and other publications.The author, Chris Callow, has done admirable work in this carefully written and interesting book which spans 300 pages, and is complimented by a 34-page bibliography, 11 maps, and 18 photographs.The book is well written, and the text accessible to the general reader.The book should be welcomed by all who have an interest in the subject and will be especially beneficial to scholars in the field.Tho book covers a wide time range, from colonization to the end of the Icelandic Commonwealth in the middle of the thirteenth century, and the collection of sources is all documented.It is a fresh approach to focus the content of the book on geopolitics at the local level in Dalir and Eyjafjrur.After reading slendingasgur as a testimony of the geopolitical power system at local level in the Middle Ages, the author claims it was characterized by stability and consistency, which in my view is the most important conclusion of the book.The goor, the legal authority owned by chieftains (goi/hfingi) was geographically delimited, and although the form of the goor was not stable as the medieval Icelandic laws suggest-their number may not have been fixed and their names changed from time to time-the decision-making process the author describes, although he does not use that term, seems to have been stable and consistent.Every goi had around him a group of farmers, self-declared followers who lived near him.In each province, there could only be a limited number of goar (the plural of goi).Their decisions on the use of force or making agreement, were driven by their own interests and the overarching goal of preventing society from descending into total warfare.I understand the results to mean that the power of a specific goi was as great as his last political or military victory.To win such victories, power was needed, and it was not obtained by legal order, but by use of force and making alliances with other powerful chieftains.The power was therefore not constitutional but came from control over land.The goar were, says Callow, a constant threat to each other and to a peaceful society.Callow says the time of the origin of the slendingasgur is older than has been suggested, before or in the second half of the twelfth century rather than in the sec-Reviews

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Northern Studies
Published
2024-11-04
DOI
https://doi.org/10.36368/jns.v16i2.1127
Primary Topic
Historical and Archaeological Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Chris Callow, Landscape, Tradition and Power in Medieval Iceland. Dalir and Eyjafjörður Region c. 870–1265, Leiden: Brill 2020

Þorlákur Axel Jónsson
Journal of Northern Studies
Historical and Archaeological Studies
article

Chris Callow, Landscape, Tradition and Power in Medieval Iceland. Dalir and Eyjafjörður Region c. 870–1265, Leiden: Brill 2020

Þorlákur Axel Jónsson
article en

Abstract

This book compares systems of geopolitical power including the formation of alliances through marriages in two regions of Iceland, Dalir and Eyjafjrur, as found in the Sagas of Icelanders (slendingasgur), The Book of Settlements (Landnmabk), Contemporary sagas (Sturlunga saga) and other publications.The author, Chris Callow, has done admirable work in this carefully written and interesting book which spans 300 pages, and is complimented by a 34-page bibliography, 11 maps, and 18 photographs.The book is well written, and the text accessible to the general reader.The book should be welcomed by all who have an interest in the subject and will be especially beneficial to scholars in the field.Tho book covers a wide time range, from colonization to the end of the Icelandic Commonwealth in the middle of the thirteenth century, and the collection of sources is all documented.It is a fresh approach to focus the content of the book on geopolitics at the local level in Dalir and Eyjafjrur.After reading slendingasgur as a testimony of the geopolitical power system at local level in the Middle Ages, the author claims it was characterized by stability and consistency, which in my view is the most important conclusion of the book.The goor, the legal authority owned by chieftains (goi/hfingi) was geographically delimited, and although the form of the goor was not stable as the medieval Icelandic laws suggest-their number may not have been fixed and their names changed from time to time-the decision-making process the author describes, although he does not use that term, seems to have been stable and consistent.Every goi had around him a group of farmers, self-declared followers who lived near him.In each province, there could only be a limited number of goar (the plural of goi).Their decisions on the use of force or making agreement, were driven by their own interests and the overarching goal of preventing society from descending into total warfare.I understand the results to mean that the power of a specific goi was as great as his last political or military victory.To win such victories, power was needed, and it was not obtained by legal order, but by use of force and making alliances with other powerful chieftains.The power was therefore not constitutional but came from control over land.The goar were, says Callow, a constant threat to each other and to a peaceful society.Callow says the time of the origin of the slendingasgur is older than has been suggested, before or in the second half of the twelfth century rather than in the sec-Reviews

Journal of Northern StudiesVol. 16(2)
Umeå University (SE)
Openalex Percentile: Top 75%
Historical and Archaeological Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.