Single-cell RNA-sequencing analysis of immune and mesenchymal cell crosstalk in the developing enthesis

Autoimmunity underlies many painful disorders, such as enthesopathies, which localize to the enthesis. From infiltration of the synovium and axial skeleton by B cells, to disturbances in the ratio of M1/M2 enthesis macrophages, to CD8 + T cell mediated inflammation, autoimmune dysregulation is becoming increasingly well characterized in enthesopathies. Tissue resident B cells, macrophages, neutrophils, and T cells have also been localized in healthy human entheses. However, the potential developmental origins, presence, and role of immune cells (ICs) in enthesis development is not known. Here, we use single-cell RNA-sequencing analysis to describe IC subtypes present in the enthesis before, during, and after mineralization, and to infer regulatory interactions between ICs and mesenchymal cells (MCs). We report the presence of nine phenotypically distinct IC subtypes, including B cells, macrophages, neutrophils, and T cells. We find that specific IC subtypes may promote MC-proliferation and differentiation, and that MCs may regulate IC phenotype and autoimmunity. Our findings suggest that bidirectional regulatory interactions between ICs and MCs may be important to enthesis mineralization, and suggest that progenitor MCs have a unique ability to limit autoimmunity during development.